Hey fellas,

Are these deer the same deer? The night pic and head down i think so. The other two pics I think is a deifferent deer, a younger one. My brother thinks theyre all the same buck. Let me know what yall think please!

Thanks,
Kev

I think 1,3,4 same deer , can't tell about 2

Probably the same. I have seen some deer that look nothing a like just from the angle but they are. With the head down might look different but is probably the same. They are all too alike to not be the same.

Thanks. Would you reckon about 4 years old or older?

Looks 4.5 to me. If on lease and that is the oldest and biggest then time to shoot. Great deer. Hocks are real light but those are from early Oct so rut might have him long gone by now. Hopefully not.

Same here. I think at least 4.5. Depending on your ideals, probably a shooter. Good luck!

^^^^^

They all look pretty close I'd say.

I think that you are looking at the same buck. probably 4.5 healthy and good genetics. IMO!

All the same

SAME

Thanks guys. Id have a hard time passing on him. Brother wont have a problem popping him either! Last one took me 3 years to even see, so probably best to get him in his prime, although after rut! Heres one that took 3 seasons

Mature, I'd take him if I got a chance. Hopefully he hasn't broke any points off. Have one like that with a broke brow tine, saved his life this year!