You should remove the part in your original asking what others thoughts are if your gonna get offended. I'm sure not many care if you post on here or not.

Lol you have got to be kidding right? Im sorry I hurt someones feelings calling that 120 inch 8 point is a cull. You sir are the reason people like me dont post pictures of deer or post on this website at all....

I would hate to show the pictures of the 170 we are hunting because someone else might "Never see a deer like that in their lives"

lmao.... happy hunting my people!

Tough to tell from those pics, but I would say 4.5 and yes it is a cull. Doesn't matter to me if you cull it for inferior genetics or cull it for management purposes, or let someone shoot it as a trophy. If you take a deer out of the herd for any reason, you just "culled" the herd.

With as many people on here that post deer like this, I am shocked at some of the comments. What difference does it make if he calls it a cull or management deer? Most the time, the only difference that means to me is the price tag.

And if you get offended because someone has bigger deer than you or would cull a deer that you might have on your wall, you have a problem. I have a 5.5 yo ten on my wall that scored 132" and I have been on ranches that "cull" that deer as a management buck and STX would have shot him at 1.5 as a cull.

Tough to tell from those pics, but I would say 4.5 and yes it is a cull. Doesn't matter to me if you cull it for inferior genetics or cull it for management purposes, or let someone shoot it as a trophy. If you take a deer out of the herd for any reason, you just "culled" the herd.

With as many people on here that post deer like this, I am shocked at some of the comments. What difference does it make if he calls it a cull or management deer? Most the time, the only difference that means to me is the price tag.

And if you get offended because someone has bigger deer than you or would cull a deer that you might have on your wall, you have a problem. I have a 5.5 yo ten on my wall that scored 132" and I have been on ranches that "cull" that deer as a management buck and STX would have shot him at 1.5 as a cull.

Is it deer season yet? Kill the buck if you don't like him and call him what you want

everything is relative.

Or kill him if you do like him... He'll make good sausage!

Muscle him out and run the steaks thru a tenderizer and you won't know he was a buck if you kill him first weekend.

Y'all are all wrong about Stx. He would have started that buck on Enfamil as a fawn, soon graduating him onto straight blubber rich seal milk, and followed by protein shakes and muscle max builder by the age of two.

By this age that buck would have been a 200 inch monster on Stx's ranches.

I wonder if he knows he's a cull.

Nope...it is kind of like short people, they always think they are taller than they really are