Thanks for clarifying. That's all I was trying to do. I looked at original posters pictures again a little harder. I can see 4 1/2. The way he has his head down and forward makes him look younger to me. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Cheers

The first deer is 4 maybe 5. Really need more and better pictures. The second deer easy 6 plus. Nobody mentioned his skid plates on his knees! Thick brisket, sway back, short looking legs. Mature bucks typically don't develop those until age 5+.