3 bucks...which one is widest and which one is narrowest. Also inside spreads on each one of the bucks posted below Front on pictures or the best frontal I have. Also for grins which is the oldest and which scores the most.
1.

2.

3.

Bottom is widest, then top, then middle

There is still time to recant your guesses...

Is it true you've retired?

Outstanding looking bucks Sir!

Widest - 1
Oldest. - 3
Highest score - 2

Yes sir!

I meant from being down on AR's.... Just kidding about that. Do you get to hunt more nowadays or still about the same? Same old lease?

Oh I'm still firm on my stance against AR's, not retired from that, haha. I'm still on the same lease of over 30+ years. We've only had 3 doe taken off of it this season. Just a couple of legal bucks have shown up on game cams. Still got hogs, mostly nocturnal. I could hunt more now but have been catching up on all the chores, maintenance and "home improvements" that I've been slacking for years due to being employed (haha), so that's been occupying a lot of my so called free time.

Beautiful animal

Widest 1
Highest Score 2
Oldest 3

#1 22 4/8" Inside
#3 23 6/8" Inside
#2 24 2/8" Inside

#2 scores the Most
#3 Score 2nd most
#1 is a cull that I will come get out of your gene pool free of charge

I cannot tell which is the oldest from these pictures. Honestly they all look to be within a year of one another here.

I will give you a hint on these bucks....2 of them are exactly the same width and one is a little different. My WAG on width on them after seeing them was 23" to 24"...maybe 25" on one of them not knowing how large or small of body they were.

all incredible looking deer. my need to dicern those differences stopped long before a deer looked anything like that.

Middle widest
1 and 3 same

What I win?

Glad to see you back on here STX, always love your pics and your questions!

I could see #2 going widest since his right side just keeps going out and never really turns in.

#1 and #3 are amazing animals, and if I had to guess I would say #2 and #3 are the same and #1 is slightly more narrow, but not by much.

Score wise, I would love any of those animals. I think #2 is highest score, followed by #3 and then #1.

Beautiful specimens. Do you have dead deer pics and measurements for all these? Would love to see the tine lengths on the #2 and #3

For being wrong?

Sure, why not

Sorry that I don't have better pics since I only have a few on my cell phone I took. The last buck you really can't see to much in that one photo I do have...it is a bad photo. I was not taking photos that day and was busy with taking care of deer after dark. These photos do not help judging the width at all just perspective on them. They don't show tine length at all. The first deer I found his sheds from last year and he grossed around 210 last year. The other two I did not find the a shed off of.

These deer pics are simply amazing.

Any idea what caused the "acorning" in the first deer's antlers? And did he have that on the sheds you found from last year?

I still stand by the #2 and #3 being same width but scorewise, @2 takes him.

The mass scores on those bruisers must have been immense

#1 widest, #2 oldest. #2 higher score.

Acorn points were caused by an injury in velvet this summer. He an 8" drop that he broke when he acorned those points. He did not have them last year. It will take me time to find pics of his sheds but I have them. Found pic of one side. This the smaller side IIRC it was 89" and other was 96". So 185 + 23" inside was 208 gross.

Also for reference the weights on these bucks were from 218, 238 and 256 live weight when killed.