I have this buck ive been after for the past 3 seasons now and after looking through some old pictures i found a buck that matches up with age and has the same dime size cut out of his left ear. The only reason im on the fence about it is because there really aren't any rack similarities. I have pictures of this buck from seasons '12, '13, '14 and the pictures i was thinking might be him are from '10.
Here he is in 2012 at 5.5:
So in those pics above you can see the cut out of his left ear in all the pics.
Here is the buck from 2010 age 3.5:
Alright that's all, let me know what you think.