Ive been doing some research on this and made some calls to some buddys at Macks and Rogers. So......Sitka and Banded Black Label have to lowest returns after bought. At barely 1%. Some of the other brands have a 50 to 75% return rate!!!!!
Sitka proably has a low return rate because if people have a problem with them they go directly through sitka. I'm on a few facebook pages and they definitely leak like any other waders, it's just something that comes with the territory of the thin breathable waders.
But Sitka uses a Lacrosse boot that runs $250 and they are the only company that can fix the wader/boot seam leak if it happens.
And i dont know about banded, they get an extremely bad rap, and I can't say that they're that bad or it's a bandwagon thing and people like to hate on them.
I have a pair of the uninsulated shield gator waders, and I slightly messed up by not getting a tall version, I need like a 2" longer inseam.
I'll say they're comfortable, but I wish they had less material. I don't need a stout version, and it seems these are made kind of big.
I like the shield series though, we do some busting through briars, and I really like that outer layer of protection.
The cons to the gator wader is, the hand warmer pocket is too low, it fills with water easy and becomes useless.
It has a nice magnetic pocket, but that's it. No other waterproof pocket or anything.
I don't like that it doesn't make an x cross in the back. I absolutely hate shoulder straps sliding down, and these are pretty bad about sliding imo.