Texas Hunting Forum

What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3?

Posted By: gitthanet

What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 02:08 AM

What bird would you have to get mounted?
My top three would be a speckle belly, cinnamon teal, and whistler. My top five might include a hoodie. I just killed a perfect hoodie and it is my first drake. I'm probably going to get him done. Would you?
Posted By: Ben Lilly

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 02:37 AM

I like bluebills, cans and redheads. The scaup require a fair amount of seasoning though.
Posted By: A.B.

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 02:39 AM

In our part of the world, we want, what we ain't got.

1. Cinnamon teal
2. Canvasback
3. Redhead
Posted By: Jeff Elder

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 02:43 AM

Black mallard
Cinimen teal
Eurasian widgeon
Posted By: BDB

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 03:39 AM

All of them. But 1 or 2 a year so the tax bill stays with inflation. I want all drake puddlers and a hand full of divers on the wall. It just takes time to get a mature, undamaged bird to fill it out.
Posted By: MikeOH

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 03:51 AM

Might be a dumb question but is a black mallard the same as a "black duck". I'm new to TX and have done most of my duck hunting in the mid-west. There we killed black ducks, which are similar to mallards. Sometimes people would confuse the, with hem mallards but they are much darker. They are a beautiful duck to mount.
Posted By: Jeff Elder

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 04:07 AM

Originally Posted By: MikeOH
Might be a dumb question but is a black mallard the same as a "black duck". I'm new to TX and have done most of my duck hunting in the mid-west. There we killed black ducks, which are similar to mallards. Sometimes people would confuse the, with hem mallards but they are much darker. They are a beautiful duck to mount.


Yes. Sorry for confusion. Street name
Posted By: TTUGrad08

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 04:15 AM

Bull Sprig
cinnamon teal
Purple head Gadwall
Storm Widgeon
Bluewing
Banded Drake(anything)

Sorry, I got carried away and took it to 6!
Posted By: TxDuck24

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 04:16 AM

Cinnamon teal
Eider
Eurasian wigeon
Posted By: Aggieduck

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 05:08 AM

Very hard to pick for sure 1) plumed out BWT
2) Canvasback 3) old squaw
Posted By: pervis

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 07:51 AM

I shot 2 cinnamon teal opening day of early teal 2 yrs ago. Couldn't figure out what they were, so I ate em....smh. I got pictures of em. Won't make that mistake again
Posted By: DUKFVR

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 12:22 PM

A Banded Spoony!
Posted By: Tommy1957

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 12:59 PM

No woodys?
Posted By: Fishuhalik

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 01:41 PM

Harly
Cinny
Can

I'm tellin yall right now, if a harly ever got lost and wound up in front of my blind, the entire duck hunting world would. Know about it
Posted By: gitthanet

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/21/16 02:18 PM

Woodie would be in my top 5 too.
Posted By: Jasb

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 01:30 PM

Posted By: FowlDreams

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 02:10 PM

Originally Posted By: Jasb


Where did you shoot that? cool
Posted By: Hopedale

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 04:36 PM

1. Ring neck - because they taste so dang good.
2. Da Coot - because they taste second to Ring Necks
3. Merganser - cuz you said to name three

nuts
Posted By: kdkane1971

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 05:24 PM

Wood Duck
Ringneck Pheasant
Bull Sprig
Posted By: waterfowlwonders

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 05:42 PM

1) King Eider
2) Harlequin Drake
3) Storm Wigeon
Posted By: Cody Malone

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 06:37 PM

Originally Posted By: Jeff Elder
Black mallard
Cinimen teal
Eurasian widgeon


the man has a point
Posted By: shea.mcphail

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 09:24 PM

Originally Posted By: Jasb


I don't know my ducks. What is that?? That's a beauty.
Posted By: SeaAggie2015

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 10:03 PM

For me, the importance of the ducks you mount is the story behind each one, but if I had to choose 3 I would put it like this.
1- Pintail Drake / Hen pair
2- Canvasback Drake / Hen pair
3- Cinnamon Teal Drake / Hen pair

ps- I really like the idea of a drake/hen mount rather than a single bird mount.
Posted By: BDB

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 10:40 PM

Originally Posted By: shea.mcphail
Originally Posted By: Jasb


I don't know my ducks. What is that?? That's a beauty.



Thats the kind you hoop and hauler about all the way to your taxi man.

The kind your wife and bank account have no say in the matter.

Cinnamon teal
Posted By: LarryCopper

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/22/16 11:52 PM

I already have a wood duck, pinner, 3 cans, and (son's first) green on the wall.

1. Harlequin
2. Cinny drake
3. Plumed BWT drake

I'd take 2 & 3 and do the teal trio...
Posted By: ken starling

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/23/16 12:14 AM

Bull Canvasback
Plummed Blue wing
Cinnamon teal(probably never kill one or see one in East Texas)
Posted By: BradyBuck

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/23/16 12:33 AM

In my area it would be a

1. Cinnamon teal
2. Fully plumed blue wing teal
3. Storm Wigeon

I've got a nice GWT, Redhead and Hoodie. I've also got two pins and a buffle head in the freezer.

Here are the two pins I'm going to have done next.

Posted By: kweber

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/23/16 09:43 AM

somma yall would be pi$$ed...
shot 2-3 Buffleheads many yrs back...
ate 'em...
had a drake cinnie spend a few weeks on my tank... left him alone...
Posted By: oilag

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/23/16 01:43 PM

Saving my monies to mount these guys. Shot this limit last day of the season last year.

Posted By: Wacm

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/23/16 02:00 PM

Originally Posted By: Hopedale
1. Ring neck - because they taste so dang good.
2. Da Coot - because they taste second to Ring Necks
3. Merganser - cuz you said to name three

nuts


Ha you are a bonafide coon azz

Canvas back
Cinnamon teal
Woody
Posted By: SeaAggie2015

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/23/16 07:08 PM

Originally Posted By: BradyBuck


That's about as pretty a pintail as you can get. Awesome Pair!
Posted By: No Choke

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/24/16 04:29 AM

Have all the teal family and a pair of Canvasbacks. Just wish that I wouldn't have passed on Whistlers when I was still back in TX.
Posted By: No Choke

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/24/16 04:31 AM

Did ya drug em or shoot em the legs? No blood or ruffled feathers. Great looking birds there.
Posted By: hoof n wings

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/24/16 02:57 PM

Cinnamon Teal drake
Storm Widgeon
Tree duck
Wood duck
Bluewing Teal
Mallard
Gadwall
Dark/Dusky/Black Mallard

I'm planning for future years, already have a Bufflehead, Pintail and GWT
Posted By: smirly22

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/24/16 03:52 PM

1.Drake wood duck, 2. Canvasback 3. Pintail Drake 4. Cinnamon teal if i get lucky.
Got my first Canvasback this morning!
Posted By: swmays

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/24/16 04:02 PM

Wood duck pair
Canvasback pair
Pintail pair
Posted By: TOMCAT21

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/25/16 03:30 PM

Banded Mallard - got it
Banded Woodie - got it
Banded Black Duck - got it
Banded Pintail - still need it
Posted By: DeerBeAfraid

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/26/16 06:33 PM

Canvasback
Perfect Widgeon
Black Mallard
Posted By: ducknbass

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/27/16 01:56 AM

Lots to choose from
I'd like a black, mottled and a cinnamon. No specific order really.
Posted By: Baldpate

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/29/16 06:49 PM

1) Mature Snow Goose - got it, Dang hard to get because you have 10,000 eyes looking you over
2) Fully Barred up Speck - got it
3) Black Duck - got it (not the Mexican Duck, no offense meant!)- got it
4) Bufflehead and Goldeneye drake - don't got it!
5) I think a mature Gadwall drake with that faint purple cast to their heads, is a beautiful but understated bird.
Posted By: gitthanet

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 02:16 AM

I thought I’d bring this back. It’s old but I never posted the mount. I’m glad to have it.
[Linked Image]
Posted By: TrackQuack

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 04:01 AM

Pat did these for me, shot all three on the same morning in January at a very popular public spot close to DFW..... I know everyone likes a cinnamon because of how rare they are for us but a plumed out BWT is my favorite.

Attached picture IMG_4284.JPG
Posted By: Duck_Hunter

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 04:53 AM

Originally Posted by gitthanet
I thought I’d bring this back. It’s old but I never posted the mount. I’m glad to have it.
[Linked Image]


That is a STUD Merganser. Great mount.
Posted By: BradyBuck

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 12:53 PM

I have a hoodie, green wing and red head but my top birds would be:

Storm wigeon
Cinnamon teal
Blue wing teal

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
Posted By: jnd59

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 01:17 PM

Can (I ate the last one I shot 40 years ago)
Cin teal
Ring neck (probably do that one this yr)

Ring neck isn't top of list but it's time to put one on the wall. It's what I shot most with my dad when I was young.
Posted By: Whack n stack

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 02:42 PM

as for number one trophy 'bird' it would be an all white pigeon, wanted it since i was 12. got him two years ago and he is mounted up. for waterfowl it would be 1. storm widgeon 2. full plumage drake northern shovelor 3. great looking snow goose as i have never shot a snow goose. i would like a teal trio like the awesome mount above.
Posted By: Gulfgoose

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 02:49 PM

Have killed everything in our flyway, including a few cins. Not big on mounting birds but you can bet your last dollar that Blue Phase Ross is going on the wall when he pops up. Anything with a radio tracker will get the nod also.
Posted By: mallardking

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 03:38 PM

1. Golden Eye Pair. (I actually shot a pair while guiding a group but they wanted it so had to give it to them.)
2. Cinnamon Teal
3. Wood Duck
Posted By: 68A

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 04:23 PM

I’m not big on putting birds on the wall, only have one.
But, if I ever get the chance, I’d take a harlequin, king eider, cinnamon/silver teal and a mandarin straight to the taxi.
Posted By: LarryCopper

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/09/18 04:28 PM

Originally Posted by TrackQuack
Pat did these for me, shot all three on the same morning in January at a very popular public spot close to DFW..... I know everyone likes a cinnamon because of how rare they are for us but a plumed out BWT is my favorite.

Pretty much exactly what I'd do. Except I'd swap the cinny and GWT. Cinnies are leaders, GWT are followers.
Posted By: aerangis

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/10/18 10:16 AM

Originally Posted by 68A
I’m not big on putting birds on the wall.


Same here.

A field biologist/bird watcher/professional photographer changed my perspective after my wife and I were invited over for dinner. I was much more impressed with his waterfowl photographs than Iwould be with a stuffed dead bird I killed on a hunt.

Most impressive mounts I've ever seen was a collection of South American Arachnids pinned on velvet in flat display cases. The Giant Bird Eating Spider was the piece de resistance.

Spiders don't typically bother me or my wife, In the summer, we see tarantulas walking around most days and scoot them off the road and fish them out of the pool several times a week. We find them in the garages and house once or twice during the summer and they get scooped up and put outside. If the same situations occurred with Giant Bird Eaters, I'd move. If a cat was analogous to a tarantula, a Giant Bird Eater would be a tiger. Their size, the speed of the live specimen he kept chasing and killing an adult rat, was impressive. to put it mildly.

A mounted specimen would get a heck of a lot of attention for sure
Posted By: jnd59

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/10/18 04:04 PM

I lived in the Amazon for a time. Never saw a giant bird eater but i saw enough 5" scorpions and bushmasters for a lifetime. Saw a jaguar too. Most things would prefer to kill you down there.
Posted By: Merican Duck Hunter

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/12/18 06:41 PM

1, Cinnamon Teal
2, Bull Can
3, Black Duck
Posted By: STXHO

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/13/18 12:24 AM

Bull sprigs are my favorite.
Posted By: BDB

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/13/18 02:26 AM

Originally Posted by SeaAggie2015
For me, the importance of the ducks you mount is the story behind each one, but if I had to choose 3 I would put it like this.
1- Pintail Drake / Hen pair
2- Canvasback Drake / Hen pair
3- Cinnamon Teal Drake / Hen pair

ps- I really like the idea of a drake/hen mount rather than a single bird mount.


I've got 1 and 3 and 2 is tops on the wish list
Posted By: aerangis

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/13/18 09:23 AM

Originally Posted by BradyBuck
I have a hoodie, green wing and red head but my top birds would be:

Storm wigeon
Cinnamon teal
Blue wing teal
]


I'm not into mounts but that BW is a work of art.


Posted By: Vern1

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/13/18 01:25 PM

Any of the great aerial hunters and a few of the more colorful ducks!

But my weapon of choice for taking those would be a camera and hang the pic on the wall.
Posted By: panther

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 11/13/18 03:07 PM

Whooping crane
Posted By: brazosboyt

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/13/18 02:47 AM

Got 2/3 top trophy birds today. Don’t think I’ll be getting the king eider here in Tx...,

Nice storm.
[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

And a bpr that I’ve been watching on the farm for over a week. Had it swing inside 60 yds twice and passed. First small group today and Bazinga.

[Linked Image]


[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
Posted By: kmon11

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/13/18 03:00 AM

The one I regret eating and not getting mounted is a Black Mallard I killed while in College.
Posted By: SpoonieGod

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/13/18 05:36 PM

1) Spooney
2) Widgon
3) Mallard
Posted By: bull279

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/18/18 04:04 AM

Originally Posted by 68A
But, if I ever get the chance, I’d take a ... mandarin straight to the taxi.



THIS RIGHT HERE!!!
Posted By: txtrophy85

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/18/18 04:56 AM

I have a pintail drake, hoodie, GWT and a red head on the wall.

Shot a cinnamon deal but got the hen instead of the drake.

In south Texas we don’t get many mallards, so on of those and a big canvasback are the two I want on the wall next.
Posted By: Ridn9high

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/18/18 06:20 PM

Cinnamon Teal
Harlequin
Eider
Posted By: Trozacky

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/18/18 06:50 PM

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

Heres my pride and joy duck taxidermy! King and Cinnamon would round out my top 3!
Posted By: CCBIRDDOGMAN

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/19/18 06:07 PM

My favorite is my Bufflehead
Posted By: thomas_z71

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/19/18 08:20 PM

Of the duck species I've taken before in this area, my next ones to mount if I ever get good ones are gonna be:

1. Widgeon
2. Pintail

Of course if I happen to drop something rare like a cinnamon teal or maybe a decked out blue wing late in the season, then those would go to #1.
Posted By: QMC SW/EXW

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/19/18 09:15 PM

I was stationed in VA for many years in the USN and I always tried for the permits for these in both VA and NC. Got my share of permits and took a few. Tundra Swan. This one is a juvenile I shot for the pot. Something about a flock of birds all weighing over 20 lbs coming into the dekes was special.

[Linked Image]

Never mounted one, but to me they would be the top bird. I do have a Goldeneye drake and Woodie drake mounted though.
Posted By: Bluesea112

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/23/18 08:59 PM

1. Pintail Drake
2. Wood Duck Drake
3. Mallard Drake

If Mandarin ducks ever make a showing in North America again, then I would have to ad a drake to my list.
Posted By: Bluesea112

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 12/23/18 09:00 PM

Those are beautiful, Trozacky.
Posted By: Jiggamitch

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 01/11/19 12:31 AM

Scouting a farm pond that I'm taking my son to for his first hunt and there is a drake canvasback on the water. I hope he comes back Saturday!
Posted By: colt45-90

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 01/11/19 12:40 AM

double breasted bed thrasher
Posted By: beaversnipe

Re: What bird do you consider a "trophy"? Top 3? - 01/11/19 12:50 AM

nothing beats a whooping crane, preferably with a transmitter
© 2024 Texas Hunting Forum