Texas Hunting Forum

Overkill?

Posted By: DeRico

Overkill? - 04/15/20 08:08 PM

In the market for a scope to put onto an Ar upper that I am going to purchase. Question is that I'll mostly be shooting targets at 2-300 yards with 77gr OTM(or whatever works best), with that said is this scope overkill?


Here's the upper I intend to purchase.

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]


18" Stainless steel BCM barrel.

Thanks!
Posted By: TFF Caribou

Re: Overkill? - 04/15/20 08:14 PM

if you already own it, go ahead, but i dont think i would want a fixed 10x on an AR shooting at 200-300 yards. but it wouldnt be the worst thing for sure. depends on what you intend to be shooting.
Posted By: Tactical Cowboy

Re: Overkill? - 04/15/20 08:18 PM

I don’t think that would be bad for a mid distance target gun.
Posted By: DeRico

Re: Overkill? - 04/15/20 08:44 PM

Mostly Paper or steel. Range will vary too, not going to be shooting long distance. Might use it for a hunting hogs, depending on how light it is.
Posted By: 603Country

Re: Overkill? - 04/15/20 10:38 PM

I wouldn’t normally hunt with a fixed 10 power, though I did have one on my 220 Swift for a few years. And, I normally have my variable scope on 8 power for deer, pigs, and coyote, so that’s not too dissimilar, so 10 power will work, even if not ideal. I went into heavy brush yesterday after a badly wounded hog, and I cranked down my scope to 3 power. 10 power would not have been great in that instance.
Posted By: TFF Caribou

Re: Overkill? - 04/16/20 12:10 AM

Originally Posted by DeRico
Mostly Paper or steel. Range will vary too, not going to be shooting long distance. Might use it for a hunting hogs, depending on how light it is.


Then yeah, if you already own it, use it and see how it does. If you are going to be buying a scope, I’d go variable power.
Posted By: DeRico

Re: Overkill? - 04/16/20 12:31 AM

Originally Posted by Tff caribou
Originally Posted by DeRico
Mostly Paper or steel. Range will vary too, not going to be shooting long distance. Might use it for a hunting hogs, depending on how light it is.


Then yeah, if you already own it, use it and see how it does. If you are going to be buying a scope, I’d go variable power.


Okay cool, I don't own it but was trying to see if that would be a good option.
Posted By: Korean Redneck

Re: Overkill? - 04/16/20 02:47 AM

I would think if hunting is even a possibility then I'd look for something with a variable magnification. The lower end is more helpful than I thought it was when I started shooting. I guess I have a bit overkill but unlike my 2.5-10x trijicon accupower on a similar setup. It is sort of my more accurate ar.
Posted By: J.G.

Re: Overkill? - 04/16/20 01:40 PM

Originally Posted by DeRico
Originally Posted by Tff caribou
Originally Posted by DeRico
Mostly Paper or steel. Range will vary too, not going to be shooting long distance. Might use it for a hunting hogs, depending on how light it is.


Then yeah, if you already own it, use it and see how it does. If you are going to be buying a scope, I’d go variable power.


Okay cool, I don't own it but was trying to see if that would be a good option.


It is a good option for what you're doing with it. They are a whole lot of scope for not much money.
Posted By: Pitchfork Predator

Re: Overkill? - 04/19/20 12:06 PM

If you hog hunt with shots less than 100 yards you want variation that can be turned down to 3-4 power or you will have problems keeping the hog in your sight picture.......get a variable power.
Posted By: J.G.

Re: Overkill? - 04/19/20 02:26 PM

Originally Posted by Pitchfork Predator
If you hog hunt with shots less than 100 yards you want variation that can be turned down to 3-4 power or you will have problems keeping the hog in your sight picture.......get a variable power.


I agree Marc, but he threw down a pretty small budget.

He could throw on some 45° offset irons. They are also T.A.F.
Posted By: TFF Caribou

Re: Overkill? - 04/19/20 11:00 PM

Originally Posted by FiremanJG
Originally Posted by Pitchfork Predator
If you hog hunt with shots less than 100 yards you want variation that can be turned down to 3-4 power or you will have problems keeping the hog in your sight picture.......get a variable power.


I agree Marc, but he threw down a pretty small budget.

He could throw on some 45° offset irons. They are also T.A.F.


There’s a whole mess of servicable scopes for a 200-300 yard AR available at $400
Posted By: J.G.

Re: Overkill? - 04/20/20 11:13 PM

Originally Posted by Tff caribou
Originally Posted by FiremanJG
Originally Posted by Pitchfork Predator
If you hog hunt with shots less than 100 yards you want variation that can be turned down to 3-4 power or you will have problems keeping the hog in your sight picture.......get a variable power.


I agree Marc, but he threw down a pretty small budget.

He could throw on some 45° offset irons. They are also T.A.F.


There’s a whole mess of servicable scopes for a 200-300 yard AR available at $400


And you'll likely sacrifice glass clarity, and tracking. The top two most important factors in shooting precisely at distance.
Posted By: TFF Caribou

Re: Overkill? - 04/21/20 01:44 AM

Originally Posted by FiremanJG
Originally Posted by Tff caribou
Originally Posted by FiremanJG
Originally Posted by Pitchfork Predator
If you hog hunt with shots less than 100 yards you want variation that can be turned down to 3-4 power or you will have problems keeping the hog in your sight picture.......get a variable power.


I agree Marc, but he threw down a pretty small budget.

He could throw on some 45° offset irons. They are also T.A.F.


There’s a whole mess of servicable scopes for a 200-300 yard AR available at $400


And you'll likely sacrifice glass clarity, and tracking. The top two most important factors in shooting precisely at distance.


Absolutely, theres always a trade off. He also hasnt mentioned what size targets he wants to be shooting. If hes shooting for groups, or wants to shoot 4" targets at 300, thats a whole different thing than shooting a big steel gong to make it go PING. ARs can be precision rifles, but OP has specifically said he wont be shooting this at long range. So i assumed (maybe incorrectly) thats hes not building a precision rifle. He also hasnt said if he intends to dial, or hold over. He may be intending on zeroing at 200 yards and never moving it. All of that matters.
Posted By: DeRico

Re: Overkill? - 04/24/20 03:06 AM

Sorry about the delay boy's, I finally got the upper and after much thought and holding the rifle I might not like the 10x power afterall.

Originally Posted by Tff caribou

Absolutely, theres always a trade off. He also hasnt mentioned what size targets he wants to be shooting. If hes shooting for groups, or wants to shoot 4" targets at 300, thats a whole different thing than shooting a big steel gong to make it go PING. ARs can be precision rifles, but OP has specifically said he wont be shooting this at long range. So i assumed (maybe incorrectly) thats hes not building a precision rifle. He also hasnt said if he intends to dial, or hold over. He may be intending on zeroing at 200 yards and never moving it. All of that matters.


That's correct, I'm more than likely going to dial it at 200 and keep it there. With that said and the comment above would 1-6 or 1-8 be better?
Posted By: earl39

Re: Overkill? - 04/24/20 01:18 PM

If the glass is equal go with the 1-8.
Posted By: Ramhorn

Re: Overkill? - 04/25/20 11:26 AM

I personally would not be able to hold 10X on target without a solid rest.
Posted By: okstatefan

Re: Overkill? - 04/25/20 04:31 PM

This seems like a solid option if 4-16 is in your needs.

https://www.eurooptic.com/Nikon-BLACK-FX1000-Riflescope-4-16x50SF-Matte-FX-MRAD-FFP-16512.aspx
Posted By: DeRico

Re: Overkill? - 04/25/20 08:23 PM

I didn’t want to but I might also be adding the PRS stock instead of the Carbine tube with MFT stock, so I guess bipod as well??

[Linked Image]


She’s the one on bottom.
© 2024 Texas Hunting Forum