Part 2 of Age these bucks

https://texashuntingforum.com/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/8098083/age-on-these-bucks#Post8098083
Here is a part 2 of the original post above. Seems to have ages all over the place...so now based on your age guesses try to guess which set of antlers go with the correct buck based on your age guesses. I will post the original uncropped pics from the first thread to show you they are the same deer. You can waffle on your age guesses now if you want to...
Age these bucks original pics:




Now the antlers to match them with:

This is on your place and recently...?

OK, I dont mind being embarrassed by the master so ill go first.
A=#2=2yr
B=#1=3yr
C=#3=5yr
D=#4=6yr

A-2
B-3
C-1
D-4

A-2
B-3
C-1
D-4

A = 4- 2.5
B = 1 - 4.5
C = 3 - 5.5
D = 2 - 1.5

1-B
2-D
3-C
4-A

1/B
2/D
3/C
4/A

Well....so far no one is correct on their guesses on matching the bucks up.

Very intriguing. How do you come up with this stuff?

Boredom and a way to mess with my friends minds...

Well thats a pretty good hint for those chickens that have hung back on their guesses.

Most folks come on here to learn(among other reasons) and lots of guys are ready to be the teachers. STx just happens to be the best "teacher" weve got, IMO.
Watch and learn Grasshoppers, and he will teach.

Jerk!

This is great STX. I really wish more folks would post pics without antlers. Antlers give way too much sway to some deers ages.

My guesses were A young, B middle aged, C mature, D mature. The question i have is were these pics all taken at the same time of year and how close to rut were they taken?

Antelrs to each would go something like this:
A- 1
B- 3
C- 2 or 4
D- 2 or 4

I think both the mature deer have tiny little spike racks due to health. Both sets of spikes show lots of old age in the face, so they are the oldest.

The two other sets show some nice potential in the first, youngest deer. The other set shows a nice shield only a middle aged deer would have. Thus A-1 and B-3

All pics were taken this week over a 24 hr period. Rut starts here in mid to late November.

Yeah saw that in the other thread, sorry, did this backwards. Not that ly
Opinion matters much but how did I do? Any closer?

If you were professional baseball player...you would be sent down to the minor leagues.......one out of four on matching antlers to bodies.

Hey .250 is doing pretty good in baseball...

A-2
B-1
C-4
D-3

Got them all right

It was a little bit of a toss up on the last 2.
A2
B1
C3
D4