Age a couple deer for me

Thoughts from the experts on these 2 deer?

I think this guy is older and needs to a bullet.







I put this guy at about 3.5-4.5 and could be really nice in another year or two:






What say you guys?

The top deer looks about 4.5 to me and I'd say dirt check him. The second deer looks like 3.5 and looks like he will be really nice in a year or two. I'm really new at this so, I'm probably wrong, but I figured I'd chime in anyway. lol.

1st 5.5yo
2nd 4.5yo

Nice bucks

x2

First buck is fully mature. Second buck I would guess 3-4. Give that first one a dirt nap.

5.5 and 4.5 IMO