Hypothetical ?

Say its the first week of bow season and these two bucks walk out together, which one would you be more inclined to shoot and why? Would you shoot either? All for fun, just curious what majority would do.
I think "clean 8" is done growing and the other buck "Holyfield" still has some left to go. lets hear it boys!

I'm waiting for "Dandy"

So where is "Tyson"

Honestly I would probably shoot the 8 first and hope the other adds some tine length to those 4's next year!

i like this plan.

Dandy will always come first! This is in a different county, so essentially I have the best of both worlds!

Depends on how many bucks I can kill on this lease

Also depends on the quality of the lease. There are places I've hunted where either deer would be a significant trophy, but I would shoot either on my lease this year as there are bigger deer and we are trying to manage for trophies. Also depends if these are deer you are familiar with from past years and if you know thier history - i.e. was the 8pt the same as last year or is he still growing.

Great question. It always gets my blood flowing this time of year to see bucks on my game camera.