90% highway 10% offroad
Does that mean its my commuter that I drive to the deer lease? If so I would stick with the lesser aggressive better hwy mannered tires. Probably cost less, wear longer and be quieter plus do just about whatever you need. But im cheap practical and no fun so im sure this will be laughed out.
I am in the same boat (90%/10%) but that 10% is critical so I opt for a bit more aggressive tire. 2500 Dodge Cummins quad cab long bed 4x4. I have tried the Toyo RT, Nitto Trail Grappler M/T, BFG Rugged Trail T/A and now have the Goodyear Duratrac.
The truck came with the BFG Rugged Trail and I only drove a few thousand miles before I swapped. These are the slickest tires I have ever own on any truck, wet pavement they are extremely dangerous. I got stuck on wet grass on level ground to the point I had to go into 4 wheel drive to move, no joke. I could break the tires loose on dry pavement up to 30 mph and not even be hammering on it. I would NOT recommend these to anyone.
I went to the Nitto M/T and they performed well for traction, pavement and mud. They were a bit noisy to start and progressively got louder as they wore. I was rotating about 7-8k miles but by the time I got to 25k miles, they wouldn't pass inspection.
I then went to the Toyo RT and they performed well for traction, pavement and mud (not black mud, they don't self clean). They were much quieter than the Nittos. I was rotating 7-8k miles and they were wearing very good until about 30k miles when I had a tread separation on both front and rear on the right side of the truck after hitting a pot hole in a county road. They were partial warranty replacement due to wear, so I opted to put 4 new tires on.
Upon putting on 4 new tires, I went to the Goodyear Duratrac since that was what I wanted in the first place, but they weren't offered in the 1 oversize in a load range E. Since the E were available, I went to those. I am now at about 32k miles and they still have good tread, good overall traction including black mud to some degree, just now starting to hear them a little bit at higher speeds on the highway but less than any of the above at any point from new to replacement. I have been very pleased.