I suggest throwing it out to the forum to decide the parameters of the rules. The spirit of the idea would be to simulate actual hunting situations(rifle, caliber, scope, positions, distance, number of rounds etc.) Maybe set up a poll/survey, or whatever its called, and list all the categories that need to be addressed and see what the consensus is. Theguywithstupidlongscreenname can still override the consensus and decide what the parameters are. I would personally like to find out how many "hunters" as opposed to "shooters" would be interested in doing this. If theres no interest then stay with your more precision shooting kinda rules. If the rules were hunter friendly then I would likely volunteer time to help pull this off(maybe throw in on the prize table).
What exactly would you guys like to see changed over the current Hunters Challenge format?
Lets go down the list:
Rifle: What constitues a "hunting rifle"? Any rifle that can launch a projectile that will take down the animal in question is considered a hunting rifle to me. Just because it doesn't fit the miss conceptions that a hunting rifle has to be a wood stock with sporter barrel and duplex reticle 3-9x scope doesn't mean that it isn't someone's hunting rifle. Tactical rifles can be used to hunt with and probably to a far better extent than regular "hunting rilfes" but some people are just set in their ways.
Caliber: In the past all calibers used in the Hunting Challenge have all been calibers that could take down most everything in North America.
Positions: All shots being taken are hunting scenarios, most of which are on steel that has been laser cut to mimic the animal in question. The positional stuff is a great way to help hunters get out of their comfort zone of just shooting off a bench or prone, it helps them be able to make shots off fence post or off a tree for more stability.
Distance: The longest shot is 300 yards in the Hunters Challenge, that is not very far for hunting scenarios unless you just hunt over a feeder at 50 yards.
Number of rounds: This is really a moot point considering the generous time that is given for each stage. Dave Kershen actually used a single shot 22 for the 22 match and top loaded every single round. He ran out of time I think once. With a regular "hunting rifle" and a 3 round internal box mag you'd be able to run all the stages with no problem.
I guess I just don't understand the negativity towards our current format. I personally haven't shot a duplex reticle since I was about 12 years old on my Marlin 22LR and will never own one have no use for it. Times change, there is better equipment out there.