Texas Hunting Forum

Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase

Posted By: Hogfan1

Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 04:50 AM

Looking at the S.A. Operator and LW Operator and one of the Kimber Customs with front checkering and a beveled magwell (Can't recall the specific model at the moment). All 3 are priced at $1139.

Anybody have any specific likes and/or dislikes?

Im leaning more towards the Operator or LW Operator but figured I'd ask.

Posted By: Hogfan1

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 04:49 PM

Any help guys?

Posted By: NTXBowfisher

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 05:01 PM

i hated my kimber, havent had any experience with the others you listed.

Posted By: jeffbird

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 05:18 PM

Springfield makes a nice 1911.

Skip Kimber, the quality control is inconsistent these days. Some are great, some are fishing weights.

Also, take a look at Les Baer. The Custom Carry and Thunder Ranch are in the same price range as the Operator. The Les Baer SRP and the Springfield Pro are both top shelf.

Whatever you pick, Brian Enos' Slide Glide is a good lube for the slide. It really makes a 1911 run great. Wilson's Ultima lube is good also.






Posted By: The Dude Abides

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 05:40 PM

SA TRP
SIG SAUER

Posted By: wp75169

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 05:48 PM

IF thats the market you are shopping in go with Springfield TRP. If it is anything like its litle brother the EMP I will be buying one sooner rather than later.

Posted By: janie

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 06:16 PM

Between the two. Springfield all the way.

Posted By: texas_sooner

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 06:24 PM

Originally Posted By: NTXBowfisher
i hated my kimber, havent had any experience with the others you listed.


Same here. Sold it and got an H&K USP. Now looking to add a colt 1911.

Posted By: J.G.

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 07:11 PM

I've been eyeballing 1911's for a couple of years now and have all but decided to go with a Colt. Same money as the high end Springfields and most Kimbers but it is "The Original 1911" and I have not read or heard of any quality control issues with Colt.

Posted By: Texasbdog

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/08/12 11:28 PM

I would look at the Sigs, very few mim parts,match grade trigger, match grade barrel, front strap checkering and hand fitted. For that kind of money you could get the adjustable sights, and threaded barrel, if thats what floats you boat.I love mine, just bought it, almost 400 rounds and never a FTF, comes with an extra magazine and a nice case. just my .02

Posted By: ep2621

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 12:16 AM

I've owned several Kimbers and I've never had any trouble with them.

That said, I like Colt and Springfield for the money you're spending.

Everybody should own at least one Colt 1911.

Posted By: jkmccoy11

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 02:00 AM

LW Operator
or TRP

Posted By: Hogfan1

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 05:17 PM

I hear too many people saying they hate Kimbers along with people saying they love them. Which to me sounds like Kimber makes an inconsistent gun currently. Just my opinion.

So looks like its down to the LW Operator, standard Operator, and possibly the TRP

S.A. FTW lol

Posted By: atti_mac

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 05:29 PM

I have a Springfield A1 TRP with the original barrel (60 rounds fired),and a .460 Rowland conversation kit. Brand new Newer fired.
Let me know if you are interested in. $1600



Posted By: BIG_B

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 06:00 PM

I have been looking as well and had several people say the same thing about kimber quality dropping. They are saying that S.A. is making a better gun. Lots of folks are liking the sigs and ruger. ruger goes for 750 ball park.
Im leaning towards the S.A. just cause they been in market longer with 1911.

Originally Posted By: jeffbird
Springfield makes a nice 1911.

Skip Kimber, the quality control is inconsistent these days. Some are great, some are fishing weights.

Also, take a look at Les Baer. The Custom Carry and Thunder Ranch are in the same price range as the Operator. The Les Baer SRP and the Springfield Pro are both top shelf.

Whatever you pick, Brian Enos' Slide Glide is a good lube for the slide. It really makes a 1911 run great. Wilson's Ultima lube is good also.






Posted By: TexasVine

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 06:16 PM

I have had both Springfield and Kimber 1911's. My current favorite 1911 in my Springfield. Although I have never had issues with my Kimbers, a lot of complaints with Kimbers recent quality is spattered all over a lot of forums.

Posted By: atti_mac

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 06:48 PM

I was so happy when I sold my Kimber, I newer will buy again, I had 2 Kimbers, and now just Springfield's

Posted By: bjones2571

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 08:35 PM

http://www.texashuntingforum.com/forum/u...son_VBOB#UNREAD

Posted By: bluetopper

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/09/12 11:30 PM

Get a Dan Wesson Heritage. They're in a whole other class of quality for the same money.

Posted By: Hogfan1

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/10/12 02:21 PM

Well, the operator I found has sold.

So back to square 1 :-(

S&W make a good one?

Posted By: atti_mac

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/10/12 02:33 PM

You don't want my TRP?

Posted By: Prikasky

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/13/12 02:41 AM

Try out the Springfield Range officer. adjustable sight and well made. 300 rounds through mine Zero problems and slide action smooth like butter.

Posted By: birddude

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/13/12 02:59 AM

Go with the Springfield RO my is wonderful!


Posted By: reeder05

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/13/12 03:00 AM

Can't go wrong with a Springfield

Posted By: reeder05

Re: Need Opinions on a 1911 Purchase - 02/13/12 03:05 AM

Can't go wrong with a Springfield

© 2024 Texas Hunting Forum