Here are the uncropped pics. Now that the pics with antlers are posted....does it change how you would age them? I have found that people want to put a buck in an age class based off of looking at his antlers first then the body. Taking the antlers off got age guesses all over the board. Just having one pic to age from makes it even more difficult.

D is obviously 21 this year

well i think i just flip flopped the racks on the last two but all the letters and numbers may have me confused. I went first before so ill go again.
A 2yr
B 4yr
C 6yr
D 6yr

I think you are having rangefinder withdrawals....



Standing by a spike.

Worst original pic ever... But you know that and you how id age the last one. Lol

Note to self don't play poker at STX’s table. At least I didn't bet a case of beverages again..

At least I got others right

You saw what you wanted to see and ran with it...admit it

And to think you called him Post Post mature....

Are you going to give us the ages or did I miss it? Or do we have to wait till Christmas morning to get our gift/answer?

I'm gonna stick with these although C and D Could be older

My reasoning was sound, but my implementation lacked forethought in mind of a Wiley ol Yote. Or I just over thought it.

Fantastic pics sir

STx, you matched up pics but you never did give us the ages, did you?????? Trying to be a good pupil......

2
5
4
3

Thank you STX for sharing. I preach this to my family on our family ranch and they look at me sideways. I give them pictures and they see antlers - so I started handing them pictures with the racks cut off and told them to tell me what they saw. Was like teaching kindergarten in the beginning.. Amazing how shallow some hunters perception really is..... if its brown its down! Especially if its got bone on its head. Anyway its been a journey for some in some cases a longer journey. As you know each buck is like a person, everyone looks different. Some stay in the penalty box a long time till they figure it out....... glad to see this thread!!!