I cant believe this is even a debate. Mahomes is about 1000% more talented than Dak.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sW3yHLBy6s

I'm not so sure about that.

There have been so many quarterbacks come up in the last 10 years that made everyone say "He may be the greatest of all time" only to have them make it a few seasons, then never to be heard from again. Im not saying Mahomes is that guy. I like him. Im just saying lets see what he does after a few more seasons. Do yall remember how Dak looked his first season or two?

Mahomes is in a class by himself, and believe it or not he will continue to improve his game.
Don't even compare him to Dak, or even Brady, or any other QB, as his book is being written game to game, and in a few short years people will say, "Brady who?"

Ma HOMES. Prescott is getting better, and may end up a top 5 QB before season is over. But not MVP caliber. (i.e. - MaHomes)

Mahomes has superior arm talent.

These first three games Dak has had pretty much a clean pocket when he wasn't going with play action passes.
As long as the offensive line holds up and the other teams throw out last years tape of Dak, and study the last three games, and OH! when the Cowboys play better teams, you might start seeing the old Dak once again.

I think Mahomes has the most arm talent in the NFL today.

MO

Mahomes

This. Teams now have 20 games of footage on Mahomes and he's still rocking. Give them 20 games of Dak/Moore and see how Dak looks. He struggled with Miami enough to already give you pause. The NO game will give us some more data.

Dak vs Mahomes in the Super Bowl this year. No way I could pull for anyone but the Cowboys. So 35-34 boys. Otherwise Mahomes all the way. Hopefully can make Aikman update his tweet in a few years.

A really good defensive coordinator can humble any QB in the league and rattle his confidence.
There isn't but a handful of QB's now playing that can figure it out on the fly, with Brady and Mahomes at the top, with Dak nowhere even close that can be rattled.

EXACTLY!!!

I wouldn't take Dak over Mahomes if Mahomes was rolled out on the field and had to throw every pass looking backwards.

Typical pundits, Dallas won three games against the 3 worst teams in the NFL and they want to say Dak is comparable to Mahomes, even after it took him 3 quarters against the LEAGUES WORST DEFENSE to do anything.......PUH-LEEZE.

I simply don't understand why you never let us know how you really feel. Why hold backL

Huge Cowboy fan and I have defended Dak for 3 years, but I would take Mahomes over Dak or any other QB in the league.

Love Them both but I would take Mahomes without blinking any day!

Mahomes.

They both sucked yesterday. The Texans play the Chiefs next Sunday. Hope Mahomes doesn't recover.

I thought you were once a big Oilers fan. Bum Phillips had a ranch down around Gonzales or Quero. He once said that Don Shula could take his team and beat yours or take your team and beat his. Wade is now coaching out in California.

Is the question of Dak still being a MVP candidate valid?



Jerry Jones was smart to wait on giving Dak the big contract. Let the world see how good Dak really is(nt) and nobody can argue.

The problem now is the Cowgirls are playing the hapless jets next so we all need to be prepared to listen to "Dak carried the team on his back against the Jets and righted the floundering Cowboys ship, he really is an MVP....COWBOYS TO THE SUPERBOWL!!!"

Too late apparently...

Quincy Carter

who resurrected this dead horse?

I'm Guilty

I just have a strong dislike for the cowboys and I love seeing them fall from their infinitely high horse.