We each have our own areas feeders, and blinds. I feed year round and others dont. I work on my area year round others dont. Everyone chose there own areas to be fair. I see no reason to have others benefit from my money and hard work. That being said, after i tag out i offer my area to others with stipulations. No guest hunting.

As is usually my thoughts on many topics, "to each his own." The issue becomes that EACH lease will work fine with whatever policy as long as EACH person is like minded in that policy. Also, whatever policy is adopted for each lease should be spelled out for all to agree to upfront and then enforced consistently. All the "problems" mentioned so far seem to fall into failure in some or all of the above.
#1.Spell it out. #2. Insure everyone agrees. 3. Enforce it. To elaborate on "agree" I would say its better to have them "believe" in the policy and not just "agree."
Assuming the OP fulling intends to do the above and just wants an opinion on which one to properly implement then my 2 cents coming up. On a poorly run lease or one that is not well organized and/or policies are not spelled out and/or enforced then Community property may not work the best. Everyone to his own stand or area is the EASY WAY OUT where everyone really just has his "own little mini lease." Some guys will take care of their area and others will not so no problem since everyone basically has their own little lease. For those of you with this policy if you have "problems" then its likely an enforcement issue. For me and mine we don't want a "little lease" where we have to look at the same area time after time- THAT would be THE PROBLEM for me and likely the issue some are missing(you don't know what you don't know.) I have been the hunter in charge of a lease for many many years and its varied over time from 10000 ac to 13000 acre and from 18 to 24 guys and from 25 to 30 stands. We have always hunted Community stands so we are able to enjoy a tremendous amount of country and if anyone wasn't used to it coming in then they all loved it afterwards. However, Community can be much harder to pull off cause it only works if the "community" shares in making it all work. We have one member we pay to maintain all feeders regardless who "owns" the equipment and he fills them all at the same time and they throw the same amount at the same time. Pretty much the same with stands and game cameras and sharing of pics and info. Its called "teamwork" and very difficult to pull off if someone in charge isn't on top of things. Our expenses are "community", or shared, as well.
To sum up I would say if you have a small tight knit group of family or friends then you can adapt whatever policy you want and you wont have "problems" but in that situation I would suggest you go "community" and you will enjoy hunting more country and still not have problems. On the other hand if your "leader" is organized and committed and got some sense and people skills then he can put together guys from all over and Community will work as long as the before mentioned: 1. Spell it out 2. All agree 3. Enforce.
Another long post so I hope no one thinks im "preaching". Remember I started out with "to each his own" so Im really not pushing my opinion on any of yall, but instead im just trying to help which I think that's what this forums for. As usual, my 2cents.

Man, that is confusing.

Our biggest issue last year was no one was logging in what was taken. Then one member and his guests shot and wounded four deer. I heard there was suppose to be a talk about both of theses issues and I hope there was.

As is usually my thoughts on many topics, "to each his own." The issue becomes that EACH lease will work fine with whatever policy as long as EACH person is like minded in that policy. Also, whatever policy is adopted for each lease should be spelled out for all to agree to upfront and then enforced consistently. All the "problems" mentioned so far seem to fall into failure in some or all of the above.
#1.Spell it out. #2. Insure everyone agrees. 3. Enforce it. To elaborate on "agree" I would say its better to have them "believe" in the policy and not just "agree."
Assuming the OP fulling intends to do the above and just wants an opinion on which one to properly implement then my 2 cents coming up. On a poorly run lease or one that is not well organized and/or policies are not spelled out and/or enforced then Community property may not work the best. Everyone to his own stand or area is the EASY WAY OUT where everyone really just has his "own little mini lease." Some guys will take care of their area and others will not so no problem since everyone basically has their own little lease. For those of you with this policy if you have "problems" then its likely an enforcement issue. For me and mine we don't want a "little lease" where we have to look at the same area time after time- THAT would be THE PROBLEM for me and likely the issue some are missing(you don't know what you don't know.) I have been the hunter in charge of a lease for many many years and its varied over time from 10000 ac to 13000 acre and from 18 to 24 guys and from 25 to 30 stands. We have always hunted Community stands so we are able to enjoy a tremendous amount of country and if anyone wasn't used to it coming in then they all loved it afterwards. However, Community can be much harder to pull off cause it only works if the "community" shares in making it all work. We have one member we pay to maintain all feeders regardless who "owns" the equipment and he fills them all at the same time and they throw the same amount at the same time. Pretty much the same with stands and game cameras and sharing of pics and info. Its called "teamwork" and very difficult to pull off if someone in charge isn't on top of things. Our expenses are "community", or shared, as well.
To sum up I would say if you have a small tight knit group of family or friends then you can adapt whatever policy you want and you wont have "problems" but in that situation I would suggest you go "community" and you will enjoy hunting more country and still not have problems. On the other hand if your "leader" is organized and committed and got some sense and people skills then he can put together guys from all over and Community will work as long as the before mentioned: 1. Spell it out 2. All agree 3. Enforce.
Another long post so I hope no one thinks im "preaching". Remember I started out with "to each his own" so Im really not pushing my opinion on any of yall, but instead im just trying to help which I think that's what this forums for. As usual, my 2cents.

That’s terrible. Did they even bother tracking the deer or calling in a dog?

I know or a fact that no dog was called. I was there when one was shot and the person said he was sure that he hit him but didn’t find any any blood and I think he and the lease member did a half [censored] job of looking. They decided to go see if the gun was on target and it was so I don’t know what happened. I found out about all the others way after the fact. A guest of the lease member said I shot a doe his statement was “y’all may have a three legged deer or one with a broken leg. I rushed the shot and hit her but don’t know where it went “. In 2017 the lease member had a Mt lite 308 and he shot at least two that he didn’t recover. Another lease member and I faked about it and we and up that he was afraid of the recoil and after listening to him that is what it was. Last year he shot a doe in the neck and then just couldn’t put another shot in it and had to call his buddy and a lease member to kill it. I am getting real pissed about it and if it happens this year I’m going to say something to him instead of the lease manager. I have been on the lease 7 or 8 years and this guy only 4 this year and he and his buddy’s have wounded more deer than I have taken since I have been on.

Community. 8 blinds and feeders on 1000 acres. They have all been there for 10 to 15 years. A few 20 years. 5 of us and maybe one weekend all season 4 will be there. Never been an issue ever. We all have a good time and very laid back. Next door, same landowner and they only hunt their own setups and keep to themselves. Very different and not fun to me. Very weird. I know each guy more than they know each other over there.

This leasing stuff sounds like it is a PITA.