Not one of the bruisers that will catch your eye, but I believe this deer may be on the down slope, new place with no history of any these deer. Let me know what you guys think. I know the second picture isn't too helpful but it is the newest hard horned picture.
This one had me stumped. I called him 4.5. After looking more closely, I'd also call him post mature. Ancient from the first photo in August. Almost looks malnourished which is typical of really old deer. His body condition in the second photo is what's throwing me. Wish I could see his legs in that second pic to be sure, but I think he's 7.5+.