texashuntingforum.com logo
Main Menu
Advertisement
Affiliates
Advertisement
Newest Members
nmmuledeerhunter, Dzia-Dzia, TraeMartin, Beatixre, MooseSteed
71989 Registered Users
Top Posters(All Time)
dogcatcher 110,788
bill oxner 91,416
SnakeWrangler 65,416
stxranchman 60,296
Gravytrain 46,950
RKHarm24 44,585
rifleman 44,461
Stub 43,769
Forum Statistics
Forums46
Topics537,030
Posts9,719,586
Members86,989
Most Online25,604
Feb 12th, 2024
Print Thread
Are short tines a cullable trait? #6916124 10/11/17 01:45 AM
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 8,719
C
cameron00 Offline OP
THF Trophy Hunter
OP Offline
THF Trophy Hunter
C
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 8,719
I don’t see this discussed a lot like some of the other poor qualities in bucks, but I believe short tines are relatively damning as far as a buck’s future potential. I think the reason they don’t get as much flack is because you can still have a really cool looking buck with a heavy or long main beam. But it won’t score much.

Thoughts?

I’m asking in the following context:

Have a buddy with about 900 acres and he needs help taking deer every year. For whatever reason, their buck:doe ratio skews towards bucks, and their age structure is young (haven’t had place long) so many times when you’re out there, you’ll see 5-10 young bucks and nothing else. It’s not an AR County.

If told that the goal is to take out the poorest young bucks, would you rather cull a wider deer with short tines, or a lower spread with long tines? Assume 3-yr-olds.

We were having the discussion because my buddy was frustrated because no one was shooting anything. No one was shooting anything because we were all seeing a ton of young bucks. I shot a young 8-pt that was decently good looking, but of the 5 I had that appeared the same age, he had the shortest tines.

Thoughts?

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916129 10/11/17 01:49 AM
Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 29,609
S
SapperTitan Offline
Taking Requests
Offline
Taking Requests
S
Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 29,609
depends on how short. Semi short with good mass throughout I like but id say the majority of short tine bucks are potential culls

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916140 10/11/17 01:54 AM
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 44,461
R
rifleman Offline
Sparkly Pants
Offline
Sparkly Pants
R
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 44,461
Need to figure out what's available that's "old". If there's just a bunch of cruising yearlings out beyond their normal range, then I'm not sure what good would be done thinning them out.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916159 10/11/17 02:04 AM
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 10,965
T
Texas buckeye Online Content
THF Celebrity
Online Content
THF Celebrity
T
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 10,965
Culling is all in the eye of the beholder. As mentioned above there are so many criteria to consider when considering what a good cull deer is, that it really depends on your population as well as your taste for deer. Don’t expect culling to change anything as far as genetic expression in a lf native Texas population, and really in a HF operation culling is not going to make much difference unless New genetics are introduced. But it’s all in the eye of the beholder.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916162 10/11/17 02:08 AM
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 8,719
C
cameron00 Offline OP
THF Trophy Hunter
OP Offline
THF Trophy Hunter
C
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 8,719
There are too many deer overall.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916168 10/11/17 02:11 AM
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 8,719
C
cameron00 Offline OP
THF Trophy Hunter
OP Offline
THF Trophy Hunter
C
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 8,719
Put another way: does width or tine length have a bigger effect on score?

Forget the genetics effect and just assume the deer you don’t shoot get to live to be 7.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916192 10/11/17 02:24 AM
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 10,965
T
Texas buckeye Online Content
THF Celebrity
Online Content
THF Celebrity
T
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 10,965
IF there are too many young deer, I would focus more on shooting 2yo and older with less that 8 pts or 3yo and older with less than 10 Pts. Unless the property is MLD and you get a lot of tags to use, your culling efforts will simply remove mouths from the food chain. Won’t make any significant difference in antler expression other than just improving the food available for the remaining deer.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916214 10/11/17 02:40 AM
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 248
B
BooneDog Offline
Woodsman
Offline
Woodsman
B
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 248
We have kind of the same dilemma going on, so I am following this one. On 6 game cams on 1200 acres we have not seen a 4+ yr Old buck at all. And the cams have been out since May. The guys bow hunting already are seeing 5-6 bucks a hunt and they are all young 8’s or smaller. This is the first year on this place in between Throckmorton and Seymour.

As far as your question on scoring main beam lengthy and time length contribute the most to score.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916318 10/11/17 06:02 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 17,712
T
Txduckman Offline
THF Celebrity
Offline
THF Celebrity
T
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 17,712
Got to wonder if they is when the drought from 2012/2013 really starts showing up with a missing age class of bucks.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916423 10/11/17 12:21 PM
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,605
fouzman Offline
Veteran Tracker
Offline
Veteran Tracker
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,605
Originally Posted By: cameron00
Put another way: does width or tine length have a bigger effect on score?

Forget the genetics effect and just assume the deer you don’t shoot get to live to be 7.


Tine length.

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916429 10/11/17 12:28 PM
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 113
P
Pinky3169 Offline
Woodsman
Offline
Woodsman
P
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 113
We typically take 2 year olds or older with 4 or 6 point racks, no brow tines. To start. Then we will move to 7pt racks and 8pt racks with super short brows.. Works for us.... Not for every one..

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6916506 10/11/17 01:21 PM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 39,481
R
redchevy Offline
THF Celebrity
Offline
THF Celebrity
R
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 39,481
Native genetics have everything including the kitchen sink in them. We have some that are narrow and tall like you say and also wide and short. It seems to me the ones that are wide and short seem to be at least for us the deer that throw a lot of points.


It's hell eatin em live
Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: Pinky3169] #6916516 10/11/17 01:34 PM
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 834
D
D Rogers Offline
Tracker
Offline
Tracker
D
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 834
Originally Posted By: Pinky3169
We typically take 2 year olds or older with 4 or 6 point racks, no brow tines. To start. Then we will move to 7pt racks and 8pt racks with super short brows.. Works for us.... Not for every one..


up start at the bottom and work your way up.

As for scoring, tine and beam length contribute the most.

Pinky3169, where you at in Walker county?


~Dustin



"Life's complicated, man, like a dang ol' Rubik's cube, man. Talkin' 'bout blue and red, man. Dang ol' get one side, dang ol' messed up th' other side, man."

-Boomhauer
Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: Txduckman] #6916578 10/11/17 02:17 PM
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 179
D
D'hanis Offline
Woodsman
Offline
Woodsman
D
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 179
Originally Posted By: Txduckman
Got to wonder if they is when the drought from 2012/2013 really starts showing up with a missing age class of bucks.


Very good point

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: D'hanis] #6917553 10/12/17 04:09 AM
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 1,586
C
ckat Offline
Pro Tracker
Offline
Pro Tracker
C
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 1,586
Originally Posted By: D'hanis
Originally Posted By: Txduckman
Got to wonder if they is when the drought from 2012/2013 really starts showing up with a missing age class of bucks.


Very good point


THIS^^^ Most folks don't fully understand the effects of the drought. A group of biologist in our area (Rolling Plains) did an in-depth study on the fawn crops of the drought and reported the findings last year. The Kliff Notes version is:

2011 Fawn Crop (6.5 year olds this year) - Near 100% mortality rate

2012 Fawn Crop (5.5 year olds this year) - Estimated 30% of normal birthing rate, but high post-birth mortality rate

2013 Fawn Crop (4.5 year olds this year) - Estimated 30% of normal birthing rate, with higher than 2012 survival rate

What does this mean? It is THE explanation for the significant "Age Gap" that we are seeing throughout the region. Lots of young bucks from 0.5-3.5 years old, a few 4.5 year olds, very few 5.5 year olds, and virtually no 6.5 year olds. Due to the tough conditions of 2011-2013, the number of bucks that are older than 6.5 is basically zero. The biologists also noted that barring no severe droughts, 2020 should be the "Magic" year where things are back to "normal."

Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: ckat] #6917772 10/12/17 01:23 PM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 39,481
R
redchevy Offline
THF Celebrity
Offline
THF Celebrity
R
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 39,481
Originally Posted By: ckat
Originally Posted By: D'hanis
Originally Posted By: Txduckman
Got to wonder if they is when the drought from 2012/2013 really starts showing up with a missing age class of bucks.


Very good point


THIS^^^ Most folks don't fully understand the effects of the drought. A group of biologist in our area (Rolling Plains) did an in-depth study on the fawn crops of the drought and reported the findings last year. The Kliff Notes version is:

2011 Fawn Crop (6.5 year olds this year) - Near 100% mortality rate

2012 Fawn Crop (5.5 year olds this year) - Estimated 30% of normal birthing rate, but high post-birth mortality rate

2013 Fawn Crop (4.5 year olds this year) - Estimated 30% of normal birthing rate, with higher than 2012 survival rate

What does this mean? It is THE explanation for the significant "Age Gap" that we are seeing throughout the region. Lots of young bucks from 0.5-3.5 years old, a few 4.5 year olds, very few 5.5 year olds, and virtually no 6.5 year olds. Due to the tough conditions of 2011-2013, the number of bucks that are older than 6.5 is basically zero. The biologists also noted that barring no severe droughts, 2020 should be the "Magic" year where things are back to "normal."


The drought wasn't as bad for all of us. Our place is in south texas. We didn't have fires and had water and protein available through the tuff times. We shot fat deer and saw no negligible change in recruitment and have no gaps in the age structure.


It's hell eatin em live
Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: redchevy] #6917797 10/12/17 01:43 PM
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 60,273
BOBO the Clown Offline
kind of a big deal
Offline
kind of a big deal
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 60,273
Originally Posted By: redchevy
Originally Posted By: ckat
Originally Posted By: D'hanis
Originally Posted By: Txduckman
Got to wonder if they is when the drought from 2012/2013 really starts showing up with a missing age class of bucks.


Very good point


THIS^^^ Most folks don't fully understand the effects of the drought. A group of biologist in our area (Rolling Plains) did an in-depth study on the fawn crops of the drought and reported the findings last year. The Kliff Notes version is:

2011 Fawn Crop (6.5 year olds this year) - Near 100% mortality rate

2012 Fawn Crop (5.5 year olds this year) - Estimated 30% of normal birthing rate, but high post-birth mortality rate

2013 Fawn Crop (4.5 year olds this year) - Estimated 30% of normal birthing rate, with higher than 2012 survival rate

What does this mean? It is THE explanation for the significant "Age Gap" that we are seeing throughout the region. Lots of young bucks from 0.5-3.5 years old, a few 4.5 year olds, very few 5.5 year olds, and virtually no 6.5 year olds. Due to the tough conditions of 2011-2013, the number of bucks that are older than 6.5 is basically zero. The biologists also noted that barring no severe droughts, 2020 should be the "Magic" year where things are back to "normal."


The drought wasn't as bad for all of us. Our place is in south texas. We didn't have fires and had water and protein available through the tuff times. We shot fat deer and saw no negligible change in recruitment and have no gaps in the age structure.


Massive decline in Webb in both deer and predators... both are fully rebounded but the upper age class has been all but non existent


Donate to TX Youth hunting program.... better to donate then to waste it in taxes

https://secure.qgiv.com/for/gtgoh/mobile
Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6917810 10/12/17 01:52 PM
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 7,759
S
snake oil Offline
THF Trophy Hunter
Offline
THF Trophy Hunter
S
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 7,759
40 percent of a deers score is tine length so yes short tines are a undesirable trait.........


"You may all go to hell and I will go to Texas".
Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6917816 10/12/17 01:56 PM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 39,481
R
redchevy Offline
THF Celebrity
Offline
THF Celebrity
R
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 39,481
We are southern Duval County. We have always had a huge coyote population and we have observed no changes in it although we don't survey them like we do the deer. The quail did take it on the chin for a few years, but are back in full force.


It's hell eatin em live
Re: Are short tines a cullable trait? [Re: cameron00] #6918531 10/13/17 12:20 AM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,986
H
HornSlayer Offline
Pro Tracker
Offline
Pro Tracker
H
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,986
Tine length over width is more important. Width will come with age. I haven't seen any kickers on short tinned deer myself.


They make ammo specifically for hunting for a reason! nidea
Previous Thread
Index
Next Thread

© 2004-2024 OUTDOOR SITES NETWORK all rights reserved USA and Worldwide
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3