I think they are both 3.5 maybe

I think they are 3.5 but I'm not 100%. What do y'all think.

Right on, future shooters

Good looking deer!

#1 your are right 3.5, #2 may be 4.5. Body and eye look a bit older than #1. IMO

That bottom deer is way older than 3

I agree

Bottom deer is well into the mature years no since waiting on him

Agree on #1 but #2 deer is probably 5+

I think #1 is 4.5 and #2 is 5+.

Agree. Bottom buck might even be 6+

Just another example of how bad the average person is at actually aging deer. I'm awful at it, so I don't even try usually, but there is usually a huge range of answers on the forum.

Bottom deer's a jugheaded guy, and ready to take as you please. The 1st guy is still a teenager, and needs to "season" a bit with that grey face like the older guy's...'cause I recognize the grey chin whiskers in the mirror every morning
Ron

Agree

I think Red Cloud is on the money.

I think #2 might be 5 1/2

Agree with most of these other posts. I think 3.5 on top pic. Bottom I believe is older...anywhere from 4.5-6.5 depending on what part of the state you're in. imho...

Top deer looks all of 4.5. I think the bottom deer is 6-8 years old. In really poor shape

I say #1 is 4
#2 is 5 or 6

About 3 on the top one, post mature on the bottom, he needs to go probably will continue to decline.

2 could be 1's daddy ,looks much older to me in those photos

Top agree, bottom deer maybe 6.5 or older.

I think 2nd is older than. Either 4 or 5