Nice buck. Next decision is....

I got this nice buck last weekend. What do you think?

My question is this: I've seen four or so doe around my place, but only one that is old and fat where I could justify shooting her. I've seen 3 or 4 spikes show up. If you had a choice, would you shoot the doe or one of the spikes?
It would be nice to get a bit more meat, but not essential.

Nice looking buck!

I would go for a doe.

I would probably go for the doe as well. But there is a case to be made either way.

Nice buck
If one of those spikes doesn't have a milk mustache (young)....Id choot him.

I'd go for the old doe.

I'd shoot a young doe.

Doe. IMHO.

Shoot a pig and make sausage.

I would shoot a spike, hopefully the does he bred by something with better genetics.

Nice buck! Old doe or most mature spike.

are the spikes young, like last year's fawn? I would likely opt for a older doe.

Doe are reproducers. Spikes are not.

Shoot the biggest spike in my opinion. Nice buck you got.