Age/score

two different deer.... my son wants to shoot one.. usually I pass on stuff like this.. but i have my ages/scores... just comparing other ppls thoughts. thanks for sharing!




2nd buck

The top buck looks a year older than the bottom buck. I don't know the overall quality of the deer in your area but in my neck of the woods the top buck would be considered a really nice trophy. Personally I would give bottom buck a pass this year. JMO

3.5, mid 130s
3.5, mid 110s, maybe 120s

Personally would pass on both, but it's not my call.

3.5-4.5. need better pics.

Score 130s top buck

Top 4

Bottom 3

Both 3.5

I had both at 3.5

well Im in the park.. figured 3.5 at least... bottom one is fat makes him look a bit older but still think hes 3.5... top one his rear isnt huge and not a barrel with legs... he may be 4.5 not sure.... anyone else on top buck antler score... may let my youngest shoot him.. would be his biggest.

4yr old low 130s

3yr old 118ish

wouldn't argue with 3 on the top buck just going off those 2 pics

gonna be low 30's, if he is 3, I might have to see if he blows up next year.

I would say the twelve is 4.5 and he would be around 140+/- If I could I would let him walk and let my son take the second buck.

If anything, from the pics I think the second deer is older. Take that one.