Need Fast Age Opinion

I need fast age opinions. These two bucks look very similar to me. I believe they are both 2.5 year olds. One is a spike, with basically good physical appearance. The other is a very promising 8 point.

Thoughts? Are they the same age?

Thanks in advance!

Look to be the same age to me and 2.5 yrs. would be my guess also.

8pt. 2.5, spike 2.0yo IMO.

If they're both 2.5, there is an issue with the spike that needs to be resolved

Not a spike killer myself, but, dang, that might be a good candidate!

Was the first thing I thought too.

That spike is too old for his own good! Shoot him!

Leave the 8 pt for next year or the years after, he looks good. Spike, not so much. As healthy as they look, spike should be mucho bigger by now

He does look older than a yearling, but someone on here said they had never seen a spike older than 1.5.

KILL THE SPIKE!!!

Same age...Kill the spike...