Comanche Bucks....Score?

So what do you guys think? Which one in a perfect world would you shoot if they both walked out...You think 125-130 B&C?

I wouldn't pass up either but I like the top buck

top one will be pushing 125 bottom deer at the 130 mark

That first book looks mad

I like the 8. Awesome browtines. I scored him at 124 using a standard 90" for spread, mass, main beams. He looks more mature to me as well.

Let the 10 have another year.

Either one. Both nice!

I sure like those choolate antlers on the buck in the first pic. He looks to me to be getting up in years, I'd take him.

Brows on the 8 r awesome. He looks to have more mass too. But would have to look them over in person I guess.

Bambislayer where do you hunt in Comanche?

Between Desdemona and Gorman, close to hwy 8

I'd take the 8 and let the 10 go another year. Both are good looking deer. Good luck sir.

Same...

Take the 8pt older deer plus those brow times are nice! Should be close to 120's

1st buck looks more mature.

The 8 is old and probably on the decline. I would shoot him and let that ten get another year on him.

The 8 would be a great deer for someone who has not shot a buck, maybe a child or friend?
Good luck either way

If I liked both I'd shoot the first one I see...I think they are both nice bucks and I'd probably favor the ten.

I'm not to far from you. I'm off of 578 I think it is. East of Rising star around 8 miles or so.

x2