Are these different deer or different pictures of the same deer?

Looks like the same to me. Great buck

Yes and a great looking buck.

If not the same they are very similar.

The throat patches don't look the same to me....maybe its the pic? I say different

Same

Different to me, agree with Drop Tine. Throat patch, plus brisket different. Nice to have 2 nice bucks roaming around.

The pics were taken about 15 minutes apart, so I wasn't sure if it was the same deer or one ran the other out. So, I thought I would gather opinions from the masses. Thanks

Similar, but not 100% sure. Nice buck(s) either way.

Kill that buck and if the other one never shows up question answered.

Oh and call me since I have a tag left in my pocket if he does show up

Same buck you can tell by the throat patch, the shape of the mainbeams and the mainbeam tips. Just two different body postures and potion of the rack make it look different. Was there any doe at the feeder in the pictures in between these two pics?
Great first post also

Actually the throat patches is what sold me imo...Nice one Sir, good luck

They have been running doe, so they are in the throws of love so to speak. Not sure if there were doe in there at the time in between pics, will have to look.

looks like the same buck to me.

Looks like the same to me

Hmmm, two big 8s, 15 minutes apart, both with long beams and dog catchers that angle the same?

One deer, but a very nice one.

Definitely same deer

x2

Looks the same to me.. particularly the amount of white on the front legs...goes up pretty high

Same IMHO

I vote same!

Same horns and matching white patches on the throat