Opinions

Checking my camera sticks today and the horns are looking good this year especially for my area. This guy has character and main beams that cross. Looks to be 4 years maybe older and score close to 140. ??????

I'd say 3.5, mid 130s.

What I was thinking upper 120-low 130, sure a purdy buck.

3.5 for sure!

Yeah I was thinkin a 3 year old as well

Some of the pics he looks older and others make him look young. His neck is a bit thin and I was giving him a better score for the longer main beams. We will hold off for a couple more years and see if he makes it.

Low 130's

Looks about what I would think...

How much control do you have over the area? If you think that somebody else might kill him, then he would be a nice buck to take yourself. If you can let him go another year and you think that nobody else will shoot him, he will be a lot nicer next year, and probably at his peak in two more years. Then he would be a trophy of a lifetime!!

I hunt 450 acres in coleman that is somewhat isolated except the west side of the property where this deer is at and the deer can become mature here. The genetics in this area are fair so it is just exciting to see a deer with potential and hope he makes it and sticks around a couple more years.

Low 130's and a great looking young buck.

3.5. If I thought he could make it another year I would let him walk. If I thought he would get shot I would shoot him.

I agree. If your not worried about the neighbors then let him walk, if you are then your choice but he would look pretty on your wall. It could be worth a shot to reach out to the neighbors and have everyone agree to let him walk and grow/pass on his genes.

Best wishes...