Texas Hunting Forum

ejector swipe

Posted By: Hunter80

ejector swipe - 12/24/16 01:27 AM

I was shooting today and noticed my cases had ejector swipes and bolt lift was a little heavy. I've shot this load many times before with no issues. Any thoughts?

308 Win
43.0gr IMR 4064
Lapua 3x fired brass
175 SMK
CCI BR2 Brimer

Posted By: Judd

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 01:30 AM

Your primer is cratered too. Load is too hot...humidity is as bad as heat and today the humidity was high.

You need to back it down a bit.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 01:48 AM

New jug of powder?
Posted By: Hunter80

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 01:53 AM

I didn't think this was near a published max load guess I'll need to look at my manuals again. I came up with that load while doing an OCW test last year and 43.0 grains provided the best accuracy. It was not a new jug of powder it was the same powder jug I've loaded out of before.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 01:59 AM

If you've changed bullet seating depth to jam the lands, but you did not do this before, you could easily have driven pressures up beyond 65000 psi.
Posted By: Hunter80

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 02:01 AM

this is being shot out of a factory model 700 BDL so I can't get anywhere near the lands
Posted By: Hunter80

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 02:09 AM

According to my Sierra manual max load is 42.8gr
Posted By: Creedmoor

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 02:31 AM

Originally Posted By: Hunter80
According to my Sierra manual max load is 42.8gr


That doesn't mean squat.

Brass variances, powder lot variances, seating depths, chamber dimensions ...... the published data is a GUIDELINE. And you already knew that. wink

No matter what the cause, that load is definitely pushing the envelope. Like already said, back it off a bit.
Posted By: Judd

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 02:44 AM

Berger manual says 42 is max but they are notorious for being conservative and I normally start near max. So it's hot but wouldn't expect it to be that hot. Humidity sucks.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 02:57 AM

Between burn rate variations of different powder lots, case capacity, proximity to the lands, and a tight chamber you can get in trouble quick. And you can do it using published data, too.
Posted By: maximum

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 02:59 AM

Originally Posted By: Hunter80
According to my Sierra manual max load is 42.8gr


Originally Posted By: Hunter80
. . .43.0gr. . .


just curious-
what does 43.0 grains do that 42.8 wouldn't ?
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:09 AM

Originally Posted By: maximum
Originally Posted By: Hunter80
According to my Sierra manual max load is 42.8gr


Originally Posted By: Hunter80
. . .43.0gr. . .


just curious-
what does 43.0 grains do that 42.8 wouldn't ?


Well then, what does 42.8 do that 42.6 will not? When you're seeing presdure signs like that you're likely to be up near 70000 psi. What good would a .2 grain decrease do? Just because it's in a manual does not make it safe in every gun to begin with.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:12 AM

What im saying is that a .2 grain decrease is not likely to bring pressures down to the "safe" range, that's all.
Posted By: maximum

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:22 AM

Originally Posted By: RiverRider
What im saying is that a .2 grain decrease is not likely to bring pressures down to the "safe" range, that's all.


still curious though.
why would you exceed max load ?
more accurate ?
less recoil ?

educate me. i've never needed to load over max.
just wondering why.
Posted By: WileyCoyote

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:32 AM

I don't remember the particular of the load but I had a screamer worked up out of a SAKO 1st Gen Classic Grade 270 AV that all my brass looked that way & by the 3rd firing most of the print on the case head rim was unreadable in WW brass...and I threw the brass away after the 3rd loading as the primer pocket was too loose. THAT load was stupid fast, and stupid dangerous too but was doing -1" groups at 250 yards with a Leo 3x9 Vari X III Duplex on top.

A cooler head at the range I respected "got my attention" after picking up one of my spent rounds...and asking how much Life Insurance I had...and wanted to know if he could get a Life Insurance Policy on me too. HUH???
Ron
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:37 AM

Originally Posted By: maximum
Originally Posted By: RiverRider
What im saying is that a .2 grain decrease is not likely to bring pressures down to the "safe" range, that's all.


still curious though.
why would you exceed max load ?
more accurate ?
less recoil ?

educate me. i've never needed to load over max.
just wondering why.


The unvarnished truth: you may be beyond SAAMI pressures in certain situations when following the book and not exceeding the published data, and you might be well within SAAMI pressure spec while exceeding published max charges in other situations. You are ALWAYS on your own, like it or not.
Posted By: DStroud

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:41 AM

Originally Posted By: maximum
Originally Posted By: RiverRider
What im saying is that a .2 grain decrease is not likely to bring pressures down to the "safe" range, that's all.


still curious though.
why would you exceed max load ?
more accurate ?
less recoil ?

educate me. i've never needed to load over max.
just wondering why.


Who's max load are you speaking of because the Hodgdon max for that bullet is 45.6gr so he is well under that max. Not saying the load is OK just pointing out Max's vary and as mentioned are just guidelines not gospel
Posted By: maximum

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:43 AM

Originally Posted By: RiverRider
Originally Posted By: maximum
Originally Posted By: RiverRider
What im saying is that a .2 grain decrease is not likely to bring pressures down to the "safe" range, that's all.


still curious though.
why would you exceed max load ?
more accurate ?
less recoil ?

educate me. i've never needed to load over max.
just wondering why.


The unvarnished truth: you may be beyond SAAMI pressures in certain situations when following the book and not exceeding the published data, and you might be well within SAAMI pressure spec while exceeding published max charges in other situations. You are ALWAYS on your own, like it or not.


yes, i understand all that. i've reloaded for
several decades, and thankfully haven't had
any blowups or primer pops, or case ruptures
from my reloads. i did have some winchester
white box split, but none of my own reloaded ammo.

but. . . still curious. is there a reason
for exceeding book max ?
Posted By: DStroud

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:50 AM

In my opinion yes. My load for my 280 Remington is quite a bit over max because the load data was based off lower pressures Remington used to operate the semi-Auto they brought out the cartridge in back in the day.
Same with many older cartridges.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 03:52 AM

+1
Posted By: maximum

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:00 AM

ok . .so extra pressure is needed for proper
function of the action, so a larger charge
is needed ?
Posted By: 603Country

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:06 AM


My 220 and 270 are above what some books call maximum, but they weren't max when they were first worked up, based on the books at that time. And they don't seem to be max now. My 223 with a new barrel hit max way before I got to where the previous barrel was accurate. Opened up the chamber and all is well. The rifle, not the book, will tell you when to back off.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:08 AM

No.

The .280 was hamstrung from the beginning with pressure held down to 50,000 CUP (but now 60000 psi) because Remington chambered self-loaders for it. In a bolt gun the cartridge can be pushed as hard as the highest pressured cartridge (.25-06 is rated to 65000 psi, IIRC) based on the .30-06.

Besides...do you KNOW the pressure of any of your handloads??
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:10 AM

Okay...I got that wrong. The .25-06 is specced at 63000 psi, but the .270 is allowed 65000 psi.
Posted By: DStroud

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:11 AM

Originally Posted By: maximum
ok . .so extra pressure is needed for proper
function of the action, so a larger charge
is needed ?


No just the opposite
The .280 Remington, also known as the 7mm Express Remington, was introduced in 1957 for the Remington model 740, 760, 721, and 725 rifles. They operated at lower pressures than what could be used in a modern bolt gun. So data for them is still based off SAMI specs from 1957.
My loads are safe in my gun but probably would cause problems in an auto loader over time
Posted By: maximum

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:12 AM

Originally Posted By: RiverRider
No.

Besides...do you KNOW the pressure of any of your handloads??


no i do not. but then, i'm not the guy about to blow
up his rifle.the o.p. is. i'm the guy that asked a
legitimate question and hasn't posted any critism
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:16 AM

And I've pointed out to you that a load that's "about to blow up his rifle" isn't going to be made safe with a .2 grain charge decrease, even if it does bring it down to compliance with a published max charge. I don't recall posting any criticism myself, either. You asked questions, you got answers.
Posted By: DStroud

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:37 AM

Hopefully nothing I posted came across as criticism as it was not meant as such.
Just pointing out wide variances in published data shows there is no exact max written down in a book that is the magic real max... too many variables
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 04:43 AM

Originally Posted By: DStroud

Just pointing out wide variances in published data shows there is no exact max written down in a book that is the magic real max... too many variables



That's the bottom line. As handloaders, we are on our own whether we're comfortable with the idea or NOT.
Posted By: Judd

Re: ejector swipe - 12/24/16 06:20 AM

Originally Posted By: maximum
Originally Posted By: RiverRider
No.

Besides...do you KNOW the pressure of any of your handloads??


no i do not. but then, i'm not the guy about to blow
up his rifle.the o.p. is. i'm the guy that asked a
legitimate question and hasn't posted any critism


I'm not answering for the original poster or anyone else but I'll answer specific to me. Freebore is one big element that controls pressure and the guns I run over published max loads are single shot guns that have bigger freebore than most folks limited to magazines can do. Now for the answer...there are two things that beat the wind, BC and speed so I shoot the highest BC bullets and push them as fast as I can and still be accurate. I'll give up speed for accuracy but I'm always going to look at the upper node first.

I don't really care what the book tells me (I do use it for starting points), I run a ladder test and find my own reamer/barrels max. When this is done it is always done in extreme heat (summer) or high humidity (rainy/misting preferred)...once I've located that for a specific reamer it will be duplicated very closely on all barrels it's used for (assuming I stick with same bore diameter).
Posted By: Hunter80

Re: ejector swipe - 12/17/17 02:53 AM

Just an update on an old post. I backed my load down to 41.8 gr IMR 4064 (which was another accuracy node I found when doing original load work up)

I'm not getting any pressure signs now, but I'm sure I've lost substantial velocity. Either way it's accurate and gets the job done.
Posted By: RiverRider

Re: ejector swipe - 12/17/17 05:02 PM

Old thread! What were your before and after velocities?
Posted By: Hunter80

Re: ejector swipe - 12/18/17 03:41 AM

I wish I knew I don’t have a chrono
© 2024 Texas Hunting Forum