Next pistol....decisions, decisions

I just recently received my CH L plastic. I am thinking I need one more pistol to round out my portfolio.

I currently have:

Beretta 92FS 9mm
Remington 1911 RS1 .45
Ruger SP101 .357


Right now my CCW would be the Ruger. I am thinking about adding one of these:

Sig 938
M&P Shield
H&K 305k
Springfield XDs .45

Any comments or suggestions?

Shield would get my vote. Good size, good ergonomics, good trigger, good sights, good price.

I have an XD-9 (so I'm not anti-springfield), but I don't like the way any of the XD series shoots in 45. Never shot the H&K. The Sig doesn't handle as well for me as the M&P, and the M&P is quite a bit cheaper. But there's nothing inherently wrong with the Sig.

I like the XDS

Not a bad one on that list, go with the one that feels best to you

I would add a Glock 19 or 26.

XD in .40 or the Shield. You asked...

I carry the XDs or a G43. I have a sp101 but I don't carry it much. A G19 is in the rotation too but that is the biggest I can comfortably carry. But I do like all of those.

Glock 30s

Shield.

.

xds, shield is fat

I have not fired one yet, but handled one of the new Walthers at the local shop yesterday. Really fit my hand well. Looks like a nice piece.

Glock 43, or Glock 19

Sig or Shield, I'm looking at these two hard right now

SIG 238/938 and... I have 15 in stock!

I would recommend the HK. I have not shot the 30, but the USPs are good shooting pistols and very reliable.

I never leave the house without my p938.

Out of those I would say shield.

If these are all going to be carry pistols, why in the world would you want 3 different pistols that are operated in 3 different ways? Doesn't seem like a very good idea to me.

For example, I carry a P30 or a P30SK, depending on what clothes I'm wearing. They are both operated the exact same way, so I only have to train to be proficient with one operating system. I can use the full size mags as a backup for the small gun, and can also use the exact same concealed carry holsters for either. I only have to worry about stocking up on one kind of ammo too.

all too heavy for everyday carry, you won't do it..

M&P Shield gets my vote.

+1 on Xds 45

Shield

.

I've got the M&P (just the full size shield I believe) and I'm a fan so far. Very comfortable and shoots awesome!