Texas Hunting Forum

McMillin Stock decision

Posted By: spg

McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 08:59 PM

Trying to decide which stock to get for a Rem sendero, A3 sporter or Thumbhole. Will be used for shooting out of a box blind. I haven't had a chance to hold each one to compare. What would be best for shooting out of a box blind?
Posted By: Brother in-law

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 09:18 PM

Both of those you mentioned feel very good in hand. I played with both and a few others at the safari club show. My thumb hole was delivered 3 days ago to me. I know its an opinion but i really like this stock. Some people say that you twist a tumbhole with your hand to much, I dissgree. The lazzeroni th version was awful but the Remington thumb hole is boss. It has a high cheek weld for real scopes. I can't wait to get it together.
Posted By: jeffbird

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 09:22 PM

Originally Posted By: spg
What would be best for shooting out of a box blind?


A5. The wide flat underside of the forearm resting on a bean bag on the window ledge is very stable.
Posted By: spg

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 09:41 PM

Looking at the A5, thumbhole is tempting. What would be your color choice?
Posted By: Buzzsaw

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 09:47 PM

I looked hard at the A-3 Sporter, kinda best of both worlds like the Game Scout. I went with the Remington Hunter, great stock, rides bags great, great out of a blind, fits me really well, if you really like the tactical vertical grip go with the game Scout or A-3 Hunter not sure if you can tell much from pictures




Posted By: spg

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 09:56 PM

Sweet rig, I like the A3 pistol grip.
Posted By: jeffbird

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/08/15 10:35 PM

Originally Posted By: spg
Looking at the A5, thumbhole is tempting. What would be your color choice?


Purely personal preference and the options are almost limitless.

Would suggest going with molded in colors, as paint shows wear fairly quickly.

Here is an A5 in a deer blind olive drab with grey added.

Posted By: Buzzsaw

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 12:30 AM

Like that color Jeffbird, looks close to my 7mmWSM, Kinda the old "Terry Cross" pattern. I love the A-5, That adj comb is GREAT
Posted By: spg

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 12:34 AM

What source did you use to purchase it?
Posted By: jeffbird

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 12:51 AM

The rifle builder ordered it for me. Supposedly the wait time is dropping for special orders. Also, McMillan now keeps some in stock. Check their website. Whatever you order, go with a flush cup on the side in the front and rear plus a stud underneath the forearm for a bipod. Studs underneath snag on bags and pull shots. As Buzz notes, the adjustable cheekpiece is a nice addition.

Thank you Buzz.
Posted By: Brother in-law

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 01:34 AM

For vertical grips look at - a3 sporter, thumb hole , game scout , a5 (usually heavy)

For a more normal grip - Remington hunter like above

Very popular but to skinny in the forearm is the McMillan hunter

Go directly to the McMillan website as they are starting to have some ready to go or on expedited colors pending what you want. The marble colors are really nice as are the molded in colors.
Posted By: J.G.

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 02:25 AM

Manners MCS-EH1

Vertical grip (must have for me) slimmed down forend, 24-26 oz!
Posted By: jeffbird

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 02:37 AM

Another easy option just came to mind, which is an AICS. A R700 barreled action drops right in. Tighten it down with a torque wrench and you're ready to go.

AI's are by far my favorite stock. They have a flat forend, which is helpful in a blind. Have used mine in a blind more than any other stock, and it is definitely my go to choice in that use.

Also, they really tame recoil well.


Posted By: dee

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 12:47 PM

Originally Posted By: jeffbird
Another easy option just came to mind, which is an AICS. A R700 barreled action drops right in. Tighten it down with a torque wrench and you're ready to go.

AI's are by far my favorite stock. They have a flat forend, which is helpful in a blind. Have used mine in a blind more than any other stock, and it is definitely my go to choice in that use.

Also, they really tame recoil well.




I wanted a AI chassis for the longest time until getting behind one. I absolutely hated the way it felt. I still like the looks and design. I want a XLR but I'm afraid I will have the same feeling. Another thing the Manners T5A or thumb hole allow a hold like a plain vertical grip or thumb through.
Posted By: NewJeep

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 03:00 PM

I like the thumbhole. It feels really good.
Manners MCS-EH1-is going on the next rifle I have built.
Posted By: jeffbird

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 04:31 PM

spg,

You asked about color selection.

Here is an example of what McMillan can do beyond the basic OD, tan, and black combos.

This is not my photo, just linking from another forum, but I do like this and need to add this to my wish list.

Credit to shortactionsmoker, the manager of Whittaker's Guns in Kentucky.

Original link: http://www.24hourcampfire.com/ubbthreads/ubbthreads.php/topics/9553243/46/Let's_See_some_Really_Big_Deer


Posted By: spg

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 08:31 PM

Liking the Manners MCS-EH1, I'll either choose a tan, black, or olive. What's the price on the Manners, currently at work and blocked from manners website. I looked at the manners on google images but can't access the website at work.
Posted By: Brother in-law

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 08:54 PM

Look stocky stocks it may beat your filter
Posted By: BOBO the Clown

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 08:58 PM

Originally Posted By: Buzzsaw
I looked hard at the A-3 Sporter, kinda best of both worlds like the Game Scout. I went with the Remington Hunter, great stock, rides bags great, great out of a blind, fits me really well, if you really like the tactical vertical grip go with the game Scout or A-3 Hunter not sure if you can tell much from pictures






I've got three classics and a game scout. I like the hunters, love the game scout. Well rounded platform.
Posted By: MikeC

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 09:11 PM

I've got a Remington Hunter and a Remington Varmint. For shooting off of sandbags or out of a box stand I like the Varmint better. I shoot left handed so I know the pic looks backwards to most!
Posted By: clandr1

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 09:15 PM

I know this is a recommendation totally out of left field, but check out the new Magpul 700 hunter stock. Very adjustable to your preferred ergonomics, can be converted to a detachable box magazine if preferred. The basic stock is only $260.
Posted By: spg

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/09/15 10:38 PM

I'll try the stocky site, thanks.
Posted By: J.G.

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/10/15 02:47 AM

Originally Posted By: MikeC
I've got a Remington Hunter and a Remington Varmint. For shooting off of sandbags or out of a box stand I like the Varmint better. I shoot left handed so I know the pic looks backwards to most!



Looks perfect to me! up
Posted By: MikeC

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/10/15 02:55 AM

Originally Posted By: FiremanJG
Originally Posted By: MikeC
I've got a Remington Hunter and a Remington Varmint. For shooting off of sandbags or out of a box stand I like the Varmint better. I shoot left handed so I know the pic looks backwards to most!



Looks perfect to me! up
We shoot in the right frame of mind!!
Posted By: J.G.

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/10/15 03:10 AM

Fo sho! Went cold bore on 700 yards three hours ago. Then hit it a second round. woot
Posted By: Brother in-law

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/10/15 05:58 AM

Cool story Bruh tell it again
Posted By: spg

Re: McMillin Stock decision - 02/10/15 07:41 PM

$870 for the Manners, d^%*!!! Think I made the decision to go with McMillan A3 sporter. Thanks for the pictures and info sure helped me with my decision.
© 2024 Texas Hunting Forum