First one looks like a doe with antlers, 1.5-2.5 max. Would shock me if he were older.
Second one is older than the dirt he walks on. Poor guy looks in terrible shape and probably didnít make it through the winter this year, unless these are recent pics but I doubt they are.
First buck I would say either 2 or 3 and for this area I am at would call him a 3 yr old. Those pics were from early Nov in 2016. Second buck I first saw this past archery season late October 2017. He was at 15 yards and I thought he was post mature. Two issues I had with my age guesses on him were that does would fight him off corn that morning and the way he walked around just looked odd to me. He is still alive and I got pics of him in 2 different feed pens the past 4 nights. He in better body condition now than in those pics from Nov and Dec above.