Main Menu
Advertisement
Affiliates
Advertisement
Newest Members
jperez085, Reelbrothersfishingteam, flaboy71, HunterJoe, Pigmaster Yoda
63677 Registered Users
Top Posters
dogcatcher 87635
stxranchman 52793
bill oxner 46794
RKHarm24 44577
rifleman 44361
BOBO the Clown 43587
BMD 40886
Big Orn 37484
SnakeWrangler 35745
txshntr 35189
facebook
Forum Stats
63677 Members
45 Forums
453029 Topics
6260501 Posts

Max Online: 16728 @ 03/25/12 08:51 AM
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#7023329 - 01/03/18 02:46 PM 17hmr or 22 mag
bigjoe8565 Offline
THF Trophy Hunter

Registered: 06/30/08
Posts: 5348
Loc: Mesquite, Tx
Wanting a new rimfire for rabbit, raccoons, skunks, bobcats and coyotes that happen to walk past my blinds. Ranges will be 100-150 yards. Which caliber best fills that bill?

Top
#7023336 - 01/03/18 02:50 PM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
Tff caribou Online   content
Extreme Tracker

Registered: 08/27/12
Posts: 4026
Loc: Watauga, TX
I don’t think either will result in 100% successful DRTs but if the goal is just to kill the varmints, I’d go with the 17. And I think even on coyotes a headshot will always lead to a dead animal.
_________________________
The very atmosphere of firearms anywhere and everywhere restrains evil interference. -George Washington

Top
#7023555 - 01/03/18 05:07 PM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
BigPig Online   content
THF Celebrity

Registered: 08/27/09
Posts: 12317
Loc: Forney, Tx
17! I think we have the 17wsm, it’s crazy fast and accurate. Dad took a turkey with it last year at 100yards
_________________________
Originally Posted By: bill oxner
Ever spit it out rather than swallow it?

Originally Posted By: pegasaurus
Enjoy it while you can. One day you might be complaining about NOT getting random pop-ups in the morning. grin

Top
#7023638 - 01/03/18 06:04 PM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
HWY_MAN Online   content
THF Celebrity

Registered: 05/25/06
Posts: 27334
Loc: Howard County
Of the two I'd go with the 17 but the 22 mag is no slouch especially with some of the new ammo available. It was my primary weapon when I was selling hides.
_________________________
Yes a Weatherby does kill them deader.

Top
#7023940 - 01/03/18 09:43 PM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: BigPig]
SnakeWrangler Online   content
THF Celebrity

Registered: 01/22/11
Posts: 35745
Loc: Over yonder.....
Originally Posted By: BigPig
17! I think we have the 17wsm, it’s crazy fast and accurate. Dad took a turkey with it last year at 100yards

I went with the .17 wsm too..... up
_________________________
"You're statistically more likely to be killed by Hillary Clinton than an NRA member. - PolitiDiva

"Death is permanent...everything else is temporary!"

"You Cannot Simultaneously Be Politically Correct And Intellectually Honest!"

Top
#7023998 - 01/03/18 10:25 PM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
oldoak2000 Offline
Veteran Tracker

Registered: 09/16/07
Posts: 2550
Loc: North Texas
17wsm owner too - it’s everything you ever wished a rimfire could be! Extremely accurate right out of the box.

Top
#7024047 - 01/03/18 11:50 PM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
machine73 Online   content
Outdoorsman

Registered: 12/22/15
Posts: 79
I like a .22 mag because they're versatile with a good range of bullet weights.

Top
#7024076 - 01/04/18 03:59 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
cabosandinh Online   content
Pro Tracker

Registered: 08/12/13
Posts: 1499
Loc: Dallas, TX
Base your decision on ammo availability

Top
#7024078 - 01/04/18 04:04 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
booradley Offline
Veteran Tracker

Registered: 01/20/11
Posts: 2138
Loc: Justin, TX
If coyotes and bobcats are on the menu I’d go .22 mag. I wouldn’t shoot either past 100 yards with any Rimfire though. I’ve never seen a rabbit shot with a .17 HMR or WSM. A .22 mag blows them up.
_________________________
Purchase my new children’s book, “Woody”, the heartwarming story of an orphaned acorn who is raised by a willow tree.

Top
#7024299 - 01/04/18 08:23 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
QuitShootinYoungBucks Offline
THF Trophy Hunter

Registered: 11/01/12
Posts: 8873
Loc: Lubbock, TX
Looking at the chart, a 17WSM has more thump than a 22 WMR. Not that you're shooting that far, but the Hornady 20gr VMAX has 188 ft/lbs at 200 yards, compared to their 30gr VMAX which only has 141 at 100 yards. I'd look hard at a 17 WSM.
_________________________

Top
#7024434 - 01/04/18 09:39 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: booradley]
garyrapp55 Online   content
Tracker

Registered: 12/26/11
Posts: 711
Loc: Ft. Worth
Originally Posted By: booradley
I wouldn’t shoot either past 100 yards with any Rimfire though.

Not even the 17WSM, and why?

Top
#7024526 - 01/04/18 10:29 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
bigjoe8565 Offline
THF Trophy Hunter

Registered: 06/30/08
Posts: 5348
Loc: Mesquite, Tx
I like the WSM, but a little hesitant of buying a new caliber that might not stick around.

Top
#7024545 - 01/04/18 10:38 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
jeffbird Online   content


Registered: 03/09/09
Posts: 3024
Originally Posted By: bigjoe8565
...bobcats and coyotes ... Ranges will be 100-150 yards....
.223, .22-250, or .243. An animal should not suffer needlessly.

Top
#7024565 - 01/04/18 10:50 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
BigPig Online   content
THF Celebrity

Registered: 08/27/09
Posts: 12317
Loc: Forney, Tx
The best would be a 22TCM, although not a rimfire, it’s a stellar round for small game
_________________________
Originally Posted By: bill oxner
Ever spit it out rather than swallow it?

Originally Posted By: pegasaurus
Enjoy it while you can. One day you might be complaining about NOT getting random pop-ups in the morning. grin

Top
#7029576 - 01/08/18 10:44 AM Re: 17hmr or 22 mag [Re: bigjoe8565]
VAFish Offline
Bird Dog

Registered: 02/09/15
Posts: 327
Loc: Fairfax, VA
Given those two choices I'd go .17 HMR accuracy is much better than any .22 mag I have seen.
_________________________
"If your plan is for one year, plant rice.
If your plan is for ten years, plant trees.
If your plan is for one hundred years, educate children."
-- Confucius

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >



© 2004-2018 OUTDOOR SITES NETWORK all rights reserved USA and Worldwide