I have used Whitakers, they are good. It seemed like the last time I used them they took a while to get it processed then they expect you to drop everything and go pick it up as soon as they call you.
Lately I have been using Winthorst Fine Meats in Winthorst. I have been very happy with them.
I have had several recommendations about a place in Seymour but I don't know the name.
Bayco is the place in Seymour. Havent ever had a deer done there but I have tried some of their summer sausage and it was really good. They have a good reputation in this area also.
That's my $.02. Here's you're change!!