Is picture 2 and the last picture (right side) the same deer?
Looks like first 2 bucks are both in the last pic.
Wide buck is the old one. I think the one with the broken ankle might be just as old.
Wide buck was 4-5 inches wider 2 years ago, I could've taken him 5 years ago and let him walk. If broken ankle buck is same one I'm thinking, he used to have more tines.
As usual, always pics of them in October, but won't see them again until January.
Here's a closer look at the broken ankle buck: