I've seen one like that. One was a big 6x7 kansas buck. (still have that pict).
The other one was East Tx. A pict from this year, but haven't seen him 'in the flesh'.
Both were broke off just past the G1 (eye guard for newbies).
So I'll say what you were probably thinking - which is probably what we're all thinking.
"I'd sure like to see the bruiser buck that beat him up".
I gave up Hunt'n + Fish'n...It was the worst 15 Minutes of My Life!!