No, he's a great looking buck with a good looking rack with lots of character. But his neck is small compared to his body. But, it's not rut yet either, and the neck will get bigger. He still looks young, and would easily get a pass from me. Unfortunately, a lot of hunters would shoot this deer when they see the tall G2 and G3, with good brow tines. He has a making for an awesome buck in 2-3 years. The buck above is about a 1.5 year old, maybe 2.5.