Have faith in him....he is a protein chow hound. Those bucks in wet years like this can really grow out very well. Judging by his post rut condition I would say he was not all that active in the rut and more into the RedSnake All You Can Eat Buffet. If you believe what Bill Carter says about his bucks doing their best at 8-9-10 yrs old then time will tell with him. My guess is he will be better judging how far ahead of the other bucks he is so far at this time of the year.
And if you don't like him
I have a place on my wall that he will just fit into perfectly